Current:Home > NewsGOP and Democratic Platforms Highlight Stark Differences on Energy and Climate-LoTradeCoin
GOP and Democratic Platforms Highlight Stark Differences on Energy and Climate
View Date:2024-12-23 23:54:44
If there was any lingering confusion on how America’s two major political parties differ over climate and energy policy, platforms released by the Republican and Democratic Parties during this month’s national conventions made their often polar-opposite views exceedingly clear.
Republicans would dismantle the Environmental Protection Agency as it currently exists and abolish the Clean Power Plan, the centerpiece of the Obama administration’s plan to rein in greenhouse gas emissions.
Democrats called for a price on carbon, implementation of the Clean Power Plan, which was stayed by the Supreme Court in February, as well as other regulatory measures to reduce greenhouse gases, and prioritization of renewable energy over natural gas.
While platforms are more outline of party beliefs than binding policy, they nonetheless offer a picture of the widening gulf between the increasingly conservative Republican Party and a Democratic Party that has adopted many of the progressive policies championed by Sen. Bernie Sanders.
The two parties’ platforms take starkly different positions on education, immigration, health care and criminal justice, though their opposing worldviews are most plainly seen in their thinking on energy and climate.
The GOP platform states “coal is an abundant, clean, affordable, reliable domestic energy resource” and questions the scientific integrity of the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the global authority on climate science. Democrats say climate change is an “urgent threat” and call for an 80 percent cut in carbon emissions.
Republicans would finish construction of the Keystone pipeline which would carry tar sands oil from Canada to Gulf Coast refineries and was rejected over climate concerns by the Obama administration. Democrats continue to oppose Keystone and call for a similar climate change litmus test for all future federal decisions so that they “contribute to solving, not significantly exacerbating climate change.”
“It looks like two different worlds,” said Daniel Fiorino, director of the American University School of Public Affairs’ Center for Environmental Policy. “When I started studying political science a frequent observation was ‘there is really not that much difference between the parties in the United States, it’s tweedle dee and tweedle dum.’ That’s no longer the case and it’s very apparent in their positions on environmental issues.”
Another stark difference is support for the Paris climate accord, an international agreement adopted by 195 countries which aims to keep global temperature increases to “well below” 2 degrees Celsius, something the Republican Party platform flatly rejects.
“If we just unilaterally pulled out of this agreement that we played such a significant role in helping to create, this would make it very difficult for any president to exercise their foreign policy agenda,” said Andrew Light, director of the Institute for Philosophy and Public Policy at George Mason University and a former climate official in the Obama administration. Democrats “take it as assumed that we would continue to work with other countries to do this because that is the only way of solving the problem.”
What role party platforms play in shaping policy, however, is up for debate.
“It’s an opportunity for a presidential campaign to satisfy some of the activists in the party by giving them the opportunity to shape the platform to their liking, but it does not necessary mean that the presidential candidate or other candidates for office hold all of the positions included in the platform,” said David Hopkins, a political science professor at Boston College.
The Democratic Party platform, for example, includes a call to address the costs of carbon, while Clinton’s campaign has made it clear that a carbon tax is not part of her climate plan.
Candidates may also go further than what is called for in their party’s platform.
“If Trump wins I don’t think the Republican platform would have any tethering effect on the way he governs,” said David Victor, co-director of the Laboratory on International Law and Regulation at the University of California, San Diego. “I think he has a bunch of ideas about what to do that are actually bolder and more erratic than what’s reflected in the platform.“
A comprehensive analysis of Democratic and Republican Party platforms, however, shows that legislators closely adhere to those policy stances. Lee Payne, an associate professor at Stephen F. Austin State University analyzed every party platform from 1980 to 2004 and compared the policy positions to subsequent votes taken in the House and Senate. He found Democrats and Republicans voted in support of those positions 82 percent of the time.
“It does matter,” Payne said. “People get what they vote for.”
Glimpses of Trump’s energy and climate agenda were on view last week at the Republican National Convention in Cleveland. “Every time we can’t drill a well in America, terrorism is being funded,” said Oklahoma oil and gas mogul Harold Hamm, who Trump is reportedly considering for his energy secretary.
While the Republican Party platform doesn’t call into question the science of climate change, Trump called it a “hoax” in 2012.
North Dakota Rep. Kevin Cramer, a Trump energy adviser, jokingly spoke in favor of climate change at an industry-sponsored event during the RNC hosted by Politico. “We’re for a warmer climate,” Cramer said.
veryGood! (39672)
Related
- It's Red Cup Day at Starbucks: Here's how to get your holiday cup and cash in on deals
- Coachella 2023: See Shawn Mendes, Ariana Madix and More Stars Take Over the Music Festival
- 11 more tips on how to stay cool without an A/C, recommended by NPR's readers
- Why Olivia Culpo's Sisters Weren't Told About Christian McCaffrey's Proposal Plans
- Vegas Sphere reports revenue decline despite hosting UFC 306, Eagles residency
- There's a nationwide Sriracha shortage, and climate change may be to blame
- 24-Hour Flash Deal: Save $100 on This Shark Vacuum and Make Your Chores So Much Easier
- Millie Bobby Brown Shares Close-Up of Her Engagement Ring From Jake Bongiovi
- Katherine Schwarzenegger Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3 With Chris Pratt
- Use This $10 Brightening Soap With 12,300+ 5-Star Reviews to Combat Dark Spots, Acne Marks, and More
Ranking
- Republican Gabe Evans ousts Democratic US Rep. Yadira Caraveo in Colorado
- These Survivor 44 Contestants Are Dating After Meeting on the Island
- At least 25 people have died in Kentucky's devastating floods, governor says
- Researchers can now explain how climate change is affecting your weather
- 2 dead in explosion at Kentucky factory that also damaged surrounding neighborhood
- Kerry Washington, LeBron James and More Send Messages to Jamie Foxx Amid Hospitalization
- What is the legacy of burn pits? For some Iraqis, it's a lifetime of problems
- A fourth set of human remains is found at Lake Mead as the water level keeps dropping
Recommendation
-
California voters reject proposed ban on forced prison labor in any form
-
Kendall Jenner and Bad Bunny Cozy Up at Coachella 2023
-
Russia's War In Ukraine Is Hurting Nature
-
Becky G Makes Cryptic Comment at Coachella Amid Sebastian Lletget Cheating Rumors
-
Lost luggage? This new Apple feature will let you tell the airline exactly where it is.
-
Heat torches Southern Europe, killing hundreds
-
New Zealand's national climate plan includes possibly seeking higher ground
-
California will ban sales of new gasoline-powered cars by 2035