Current:Home > Contact-usFederal court rules firearm restrictions on defendants awaiting trial are constitutional-LoTradeCoin
Federal court rules firearm restrictions on defendants awaiting trial are constitutional
View Date:2024-12-23 21:05:02
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Court orders that prohibited two criminal defendants from possessing firearms while they awaited trial were constitutional because they were in line with past restrictions on firearms, a federal court ruled Monday.
Judge Gabriel P. Sanchez, writing for a unanimous three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, found that U.S. laws have historically sought to disarm dangerous criminal defendants, the Los Angeles Times reported.
Sanchez said those previous prohibitions justified the restrictions placed on John Thomas Fencl and Jesus Perez-Garcia, defendants in California whose challenges to the law were consolidated in Monday’s order.
“Here, the historical evidence, when considered as a whole, shows a long and broad history of legislatures exercising authority to disarm people whose possession of firearms would pose an unusual danger, beyond the ordinary citizen, to themselves or others,” Sanchez wrote. “The temporary disarmament of Fencl and Perez-Garcia as a means reasonably necessary to protect public safety falls within that historical tradition.”
Katie Hurrelbrink, an attorney for both men, told the Times she intended to “continue litigating this” by asking for a review by a larger, en banc appellate panel and, if necessary, the U.S. Supreme Court.
U.S. Attorney Tara McGrath said in a statement that the ruling “recognized the long history of keeping firearms out of the hands of those who refuse to abide by the law.”
The Times cited court records that show Fencl was arrested and charged with various crimes after law enforcement officials discovered more than 100 guns in his home near San Diego. Perez-Garcia was arrested at the U.S.-Mexico border when a customs inspection of a vehicle in which he was a passenger uncovered about 11 kilograms of methamphetamine and half a kilogram of fentanyl, court records show.
Both Fencl and Perez-Garcia argued that while detained defendants had historically had firearms taken away from them, there was no historical record of detainees who had been released from detention being precluded from possessing firearms.
Sanchez wrote that the decision to take their guns was “consistent with our nation’s long history of temporarily disarming criminal defendants facing serious charges and those deemed dangerous or unwilling to follow the law.”
Both men were released from custody pending trial and subsequently challenged the terms of their release under a “history and tradition” test the U.S. Supreme Court established in 2022 for assessing the constitutionality of gun laws nationwide. In New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn. vs. Bruen, the high court said that gun laws are legitimate only if they are rooted in U.S. history and tradition or are sufficiently analogous to some historic law.
The Bruen decision led to a surge in challenges to gun laws.
veryGood! (4)
Related
- Wendi McLendon-Covey talks NBC sitcom 'St. Denis Medical' and hospital humor
- Mark Estes and the Montana Boyz Will Be “Looking for Love” in New Show After Kristin Cavallari Split
- The Fate of That '90s Show Revealed After Season 2
- A Michigan man is charged with killing and dismembering a janitor he met on the Grindr dating app
- Rep. Michael McCaul of Texas says he was detained in airport over being ‘disoriented’
- Les Miles moves lawsuit over vacated LSU wins from federal to state court
- Utah woman arrested after telling informant she shot her estranged husband in his sleep
- Sarah Paulson Reveals Whether She Gets Advice From Holland Taylor—And Her Answer Is Priceless
- Surfer Bethany Hamilton Makes Masked Singer Debut After 3-Year-Old Nephew’s Tragic Death
- Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom: What to know about new Nintendo Switch game
Ranking
- The Bachelorette's Desiree Hartsock Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3 With Chris Siegfried
- Former county sheriff has been appointed to lead the Los Angeles police force
- Saoirse Ronan Shares Rare Insight Into Relationship With Husband Jack Lowden
- Wisconsin Department of Justice investigating mayor’s removal of ballot drop box
- Pitchfork Music Festival to find new home after ending 19-year run in Chicago
- International fiesta fills New Mexico’s sky with colorful hot air balloons
- Kim Kardashian calls to free Erik and Lyle Menendez after brutal 1996 killings of parents
- The Hills Alum Jason Wahler and Wife Ashley Wahler Expecting Baby No. 3
Recommendation
-
Chris Martin and Gwyneth Paltrow's Son Moses Martin Reveals His Singing Talents at Concert
-
Solar flares may cause faint auroras across top of Northern Hemisphere
-
Parents turn in children after police release photos from flash mob robberies, LAPD says
-
US nuclear weapon production sites violated environmental rules, federal judge decides
-
Kate Hudson and Goldie Hawn’s SKIMS Holiday Pajamas Are Selling Out Fast—Here’s What’s Still Available
-
Hurricane Helene Raises Questions About Raising Animals in Increasingly Vulnerable Places
-
Melania Trump says she supports abortion rights, putting her at odds with the GOP
-
School of Rock Costars Caitlin Hale and Angelo Massagli Hint at Engagement