Current:Home > FinanceDelaware judge limits scope of sweeping climate change lawsuit against fossil fuel companies-LoTradeCoin
Delaware judge limits scope of sweeping climate change lawsuit against fossil fuel companies
View Date:2024-12-23 20:29:30
DOVER, Del. (AP) — A judge has rejected several claims lodged by Delaware’s attorney general in a lawsuit alleging that the fossil fuel industry has downplayed the risks of climate change. Tuesday’s ruling significantly narrows the scope of the suit seeking to hold the industry liable for the effects of air pollution in the state.
Democratic Attorney General Kathleen Jennings filed the lawsuit in 2020, joining forces with a California law firm that has sued the oil industry on behalf of other state and local governments.
While refusing to dismiss come claims, Superior Court Judge Mary Johnston ruled, for example, that the federal Clean Air Act preempts the state’s claims seeking damages for injuries resulting from out-of-state or global greenhouse emissions and interstate pollution.
However, Johnston noted that the Clean Air Act doesn’t preempt alleged claims and damages resulting from air pollution originating from sources within Delaware.
“Air pollution prevention and control at the source is the primary responsibility of state and local governments,” she wrote.
Theodore Boutrous Jr., an attorney representing Chevron Corp., said he was pleased that Johnston recognized that claims regarding out-of-state or global greenhouse emissions and interstate pollution are preempted by the Clean Air Act.
“The global challenge of climate change requires a coordinated international policy response, not a series of baseless state and local lawsuits,” Boutros said in a prepared statement.
The judge also said the state could pursue a general claim for environmental-based public nuisance and trespass for land that the state owns directly, but not for land the state holds “in public trust.”
That ruling cited a Delaware Supreme Court ruling last year in a lawsuit filed by Jennings against agricultural giant Monsanto over environmental damage from now-banned toxic chemicals known as PCBs.
“Unlike contamination of land and water in Monsanto, damages caused by air pollution limited to state-owned property may be difficult to isolate and measure,” the judge wrote. “Nevertheless, that is an issue to be addressed at a later stage of the case.”
Johnston also ruled that claims of “greenwashing” and misrepresentations by the defendants about fossil fuels’ effects on the climate must be dismissed, because the state failed to specifically identify alleged misrepresentations for each individual defendant. In dismissing the claims, the judge said she would give attorneys for the state a chance to amend the complaint to include particular allegations.
Johnston also ruled that claims made by Jennings’ office under the Delaware Consumer Fraud Act are barred by the passage of time because the five-year statute of limitations has expired.
“Defendants have provided evidence showing that the general public had knowledge of or had access to information about the disputes, regarding the existence of climate change and effects, decades prior to the expiration of the five-year limitations period,” Johnston wrote. “This information and evidence is unrefuted by the state.”
Johnston deferred a ruling regarding the American Petroleum Institute’s argument that statements it has made relating to fossil fuels are protected by the First Amendment.
The state argues that API used deceptive campaigns to mislead the general public about hazards of fossil fuel consumption, and that the trade group’s statements constitute commercial speech that is not protected by the First Amendment.
API contends that because it does not produce or sell any fossil fuel, its purpose was to comment on matters of public significance.
“The issue of commercial speech, as opposed to misleading statements, involves a fact-intensive analysis,” Johnston wrote. “It is inappropriate for resolution on this motion to dismiss.”
Ryan Meyers, API senior vice president and general counsel, said the organization was encouraged that the judge identified “significant deficiencies in the state’s stale and baseless allegations.”
“This ongoing, coordinated campaign to wage politicized lawsuits against a foundational American industry and its workers is nothing more than a distraction from important national conversations and an enormous waste of taxpayer resources,” Meyers said in a prepared statement. “Climate policy is for Congress to debate and decide, not a patchwork of courts.”
Mat Marshall, a spokesperson for Jennings, said her office was reviewing the ruling and analyzing next steps.
“We’re grateful that the court denied several Big Oil defendants’ efforts to evade accountability,” he said.
veryGood! (96199)
Related
- Chris Pratt and Katherine Schwarzenegger welcome their first son together
- Hundreds of thousands of people are in urgent need of assistance in Congo because of flooding
- Simone Biles talks Green Bay Packers fans, husband Jonathan Owens, Taylor Swift at Lambeau
- 'Get wild': Pepsi ad campaign pokes fun at millennial parents during NFL Wild Card weekend
- Mariah Carey's Amazon Holiday Merch Is All I Want for Christmas—and It's Selling Out Fast!
- Will Laura Dern Return for Big Little Lies Season 3? She Says...
- Michael J. Fox explains why 'Parkinson's has been a gift' at National Board of Review gala
- Simone Biles talks Green Bay Packers fans, husband Jonathan Owens, Taylor Swift at Lambeau
- Can't afford a home? Why becoming a landlord might be the best way to 'house hack.'
- Austin ordered strikes from hospital where he continues to get prostate cancer care, Pentagon says
Ranking
- Trump has promised to ‘save TikTok’. What happens next is less clear
- Donald Trump ordered to pay The New York Times and its reporters nearly $400,000 in legal fees
- Sam's Club announces it will stop checking receipts and start using AI at exits
- The 33 Best Amazon Deals This Month— $7 Dresses, 50% off Yankee Candles, 30% off Fitbit Trackers & More
- 2 Florida women charged after shooting death of photographer is livestreamed
- Texas is blocking US border agents from patrols, Biden administration tells Supreme Court
- Democratic lawmakers in New Mexico take aim at gun violence, panhandling, retail crime and hazing
- EPA proposes a fee aimed at reducing climate-warming methane emissions
Recommendation
-
13 Skincare Gifts Under $50 That Are Actually Worth It
-
Advocates Welcome EPA’s Proposed Pollution Restrictions On Trash Incineration. But Environmental Justice Concerns Remain.
-
Midwest braces for winter storm today. Here's how much snow will fall and when, according to weather forecasts
-
North Carolina Gov. Cooper gets temporary legal win in fight with legislature over board’s makeup
-
Armie Hammer Says His Mom Gifted Him a Vasectomy for His 38th Birthday
-
2 rescued after SUV gets stuck 10 feet in the air between trees in Massachusetts
-
Los Angeles police Chief Michel Moore announces he is retiring at the end of February
-
Washington coach Kalen DeBoer expected to replace Nick Saban at Alabama