Current:Home > StocksNorth Carolina appeals court upholds ruling that kept Confederate monument in place-LoTradeCoin
North Carolina appeals court upholds ruling that kept Confederate monument in place
View Date:2024-12-23 16:14:56
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A North Carolina appeals court ruled Tuesday that local leaders who refused calls to remove a Confederate monument from outside a county courthouse acted in a constitutional manner and kept in place the statue at its longtime location in accordance with state law.
The three-judge panel unanimously upheld a trial court judge’s decision to side with Alamance County and its commissioners over the 30 foot (9.1 meter)-tall statue, which features a Confederate infantryman perched at the top. The state NAACP, the Alamance NAACP chapter, and other groups and individuals had sued the county and its leaders in 2021 after the commissioners rejected calls to take the statue down.
Confederate monuments in North Carolina, as elsewhere nationwide, were a frequent focal point for racial inequality protests in the late 2010s, and particularly in 2020 following the murder of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer. North Carolina legislators enacted a law in 2015 that limits when an “object of remembrance” such as a military monument can be relocated.
The lawsuit’s plaintiffs said the county and the commissioners violated the state constitution by exercising discriminatory intent to protect a symbol of white supremacy outside the historic Alamance County Courthouse, thus creating the appearance of racial prejudice there.
In the opinion, Court of Appeals Chief Judge Chris Dillon wrote that the county commissioners lacked authority under the 2015 law to remove the statue. He also said the county manager’s email to commissioners in June 2020, in which he asked them to consider removing the monument out of concern for protesters’ safety, did not qualify for an exception to that law.
“At all times, the Monument Protection Law required the County to leave the Monument in its current place,” Dillon wrote. He added that a provision in the state constitution intended to ensure state courts are open to the public doesn’t prohibit the placement of objects of historical remembrance in and around a courthouse. The courthouse monument was dedicated in 1914.
“Indeed, in many courthouses and other government buildings across our State and nation, there are depictions of historical individuals who held certain views in their time many today would find offensive,” Dillon wrote.
Judges Donna Stroud and Valerie Zachary joined in the opinion.
Even with the 2015 law, Confederate monuments in North Carolina have been taken down in recent years, sometimes through force.
In 2018, protesters tore down a Confederate statue known as “Silent Sam” at the University of North Carolina campus at Chapel Hill. Statues of soldiers from the North Carolina Confederate Monument on the old Capitol grounds in Raleigh came down in June 2020. Gov. Roy Cooper, citing public safety, directed that the remainder of the monument and two others on Capitol grounds be removed.
The state Supreme Court is currently considering litigation stemming from a 2021 decision by the Asheville City Council to dismantle an obelisk honoring Civil War-era Gov. Zebulon Vance.
veryGood! (42)
Related
- SNL's Chloe Fineman Says Rude Elon Musk Made Her Burst Into Tears as Show Host
- At least 41 killed in rebel attack on Ugandan school near Congo border
- Key takeaways from Antony Blinken's visit to China
- Neighbor allegedly shoots and kills 11-year-old British girl in quiet French village
- Cruel Intentions' Brooke Lena Johnson Teases the Biggest Differences Between the Show and the 1999 Film
- Love Is Blind's Irina Apologizes for Her Immature Behavior on the Show
- Why Jenna Dewan Says Her 9-Year-Old Daughter Is So Much Cooler Than Her
- Ulta 24-Hour Flash Sale: 50% Off Kylie Jenner's Kylie Cosmetics, Tarte, Lancôme, StriVectin, and Clinique
- Disease could kill most of the ‘ohi‘a forests on Hawaii’s Big Island within 20 years
- India and Pakistan brace as very severe Cyclone Biparjoy bears down on their coasts
Ranking
- Just Eat Takeaway sells Grubhub for $650 million, just 3 years after buying the app for $7.3 billion
- The Drought In The Western U.S. Is Getting Bad. Climate Change Is Making It Worse
- Cyclone Biparjoy hits India and Pakistan hard, setting a record, but mass-evacuations save lives
- Just 10 Etsy Finds Our Shopping Editors Are Obsessed With This Month
- Disease could kill most of the ‘ohi‘a forests on Hawaii’s Big Island within 20 years
- Ukrainians expected to finish Abrams tank training by end of summer
- Turkish Airlines says girl, 11, died after losing consciousness on flight from Istanbul to New York
- Emily Ratajkowski Hinted at New Romance Weeks Before Harry Styles Makeout Session
Recommendation
-
Seattle man faces 5 assault charges in random sidewalk stabbings
-
Why Wildfire Is Not Just A Western Problem
-
Ukraine says 10 killed in Dnipro as Russia attacks civilians with counteroffensive pushing forward
-
The Truth About Matt Damon and Ben Affleck's Winning Friendship
-
'Cowboy Carter' collaborators to be first country artists to perform at Rolling Loud
-
Celebrity Chef Nick DiGiovanni's Kitchen Essentials Make Cooking Fun & Easy
-
Pressure On The World's Biggest Polluters Is Increasing. But Can It Force Change?
-
Diver finds long-lost World War II submarine after 25 years of searching