Current:Home > MarketsClimate Change Will Increase Risk of Violent Conflict, Researchers Warn-LoTradeCoin
Climate Change Will Increase Risk of Violent Conflict, Researchers Warn
View Date:2024-12-23 19:41:31
Worsening climate change will increase the risk of future violent conflict within countries, a group of top researchers representing an array of viewpoints said Wednesday in the scientific journal Nature.
The study, “Climate as a risk factor for armed conflict,” tries to address some longstanding disagreements among climate scientists, political scientists, historians and other experts about what role, if any, climate change has played in internal conflicts over the last 100 years. Stanford researchers took the unusual step of convening 11 of the most experienced and cited experts on the topic to resolve their assessments of climate change’s impact on global security.
Working together, the experts concluded that climate change so far has not played a large role in stoking conflict, overshadowed instead by other factors such as poor governance and weak economic development. But they agreed that climate change will play a far greater role in destabilizing countries as the planet warms.
There was “strong agreement that the risks go up with more climate change,” said Katharine Mach, director of the Stanford Environment Assessment Facility and the lead author of the study in a video supplement to the report. “But some of the biggest uncertainties are how and why.”
Rather than wars between nations, the Stanford study focused on internal conflicts, because there have been far more of them in modern history, killing anywhere from dozens of people to hundreds of thousands, Mach said.
Still, domestic armed clashes, which include genocide and civil war, often spill beyond borders and destabilize entire regions.
U.S. Military Sees a ‘Threat Multiplier’
The relationship between climate change and armed conflict, even when confined to one country, is complicated, and it’s hard to tease apart the effects of extreme weather from other factors that push a society toward violence. But U.S. military and intelligence agencies have long considered climate change to be a “threat multiplier,” the factor that could tip into violence those states already staggering under the weight of other problems.
For instance, a drought exacerbated by climate change in a country where the government fails to provide for its people, water is already scarce and relations between tribes and communities are fraught could lead to local clashes over water and, ultimately, broader internal conflict.
In a 2015 report to Congress, the Pentagon pointed to the Syrian civil war as an example of how climate change can aggravate the fragility of a nation already riddled with tensions and poor governance. At the time of the Arab Spring in 2010, Syria was already under great stress. The authoritarian regime of Bashar al-Assad was unpopular, and an influx of more than 1 million Iraqi refugees strained basic services.
At the same time, the worst drought in 500 years had shriveled large swaths of rural Syria, a country long plagued by water scarcity. Thousands of Syrians moved from farms into towns and cities. The migration contributed to the instability, which erupted into uprisings and, eventually, a cataclysmic civil war. Hundreds of thousands of people died and waves of refugees moved through the Middle East and into Europe and shook the political order as far as Germany.
Trump Administration Still Pushes Denial
Despite the concerns of the U.S. military and intelligence agencies, President Donald Trump has made his National Security Council the hub of an effort to undermine acceptance of climate science. Trump, a staunch climate denier, appointed former physicist and climate denialist William Happer to the NSC to undercut the intelligence community’s integration of climate science into its threat assessments.
The Stanford analysis arrives in the wake of news that the White House tried to prevent a senior State Department intelligence expert from testifying last week about the link between climate change and global security at a hearing on the topic held by the House Intelligence Committee. The official, Rod Schoonover, ultimately testified, but Trump advisors took the rare step of withholding Schoonover’s written testimony from the Congressional Record. A copy of the written testimony, laden with critical comments from Happer, was published by The New York Times over the weekend.
In his oral testimony and what was revealed in the leaked written report, Schoonover bluntly described the scenarios that climate change could catalyze. No country will be spared damage from climate change, he said, but some will deal with it better than others. Much of the planet is “especially vulnerable,” he said, including sub-Saharan Africa, the Middle East, and South, Central and Southeast Asia.
“Most countries, if not all, are already unable to fully respond to the risks posed by 14 climate-linked hazards,” Schoonover told the committee.
The flap in Washington highlights how policymakers have long ignored or tried to suppress information about the role of climate change in conflict situations. Mach said resolving experts’ disagreements about climate change and conflict could nudge policymakers into mainstreaming the use of climate science in assessing security and diplomatic risk.
The study’s authors also recommended that the role of climate change in conflict inform policies to rein in global warming. They wrote: “Given that conflict has pervasive detrimental human, economic and environmental consequences, climate–conflict linkages—even if small—would markedly influence the social costs of carbon and decisions to limit future climate change.”
veryGood! (3)
Related
- As US Catholic bishops meet, Trump looms over their work on abortion and immigration
- Teen Activists Worldwide Prepare to Strike for Climate, Led by Greta Thunberg
- Trump: America First on Fossil Fuels, Last on Climate Change
- Prospect of Chinese spy base in Cuba unsettles Washington
- NFL playoff picture Week 10: Lions stay out in front of loaded NFC field
- Fly-Fishing on Montana’s Big Hole River, Signs of Climate Change Are All Around
- Hoda Kotb Recalls Moving Moment With Daughter Hope's Nurse Amid Recent Hospitalization
- Doctors and advocates tackle a spike of abortion misinformation – in Spanish
- Gavin Rossdale Makes Rare Public Appearance With Girlfriend Xhoana Xheneti
- Francia Raisa Pleads With Critics to Stop Online Bullying Amid Selena Gomez Drama
Ranking
- FBI raids New York City apartment of Polymarket CEO Shayne Coplan, reports say
- Trump seeks new trial or reduced damages in E. Jean Carroll sexual abuse case
- Sia Marries Dan Bernard During Intimate Italian Ceremony: See the Wedding Photos
- Today’s Climate: Aug. 2, 2010
- Oil Industry Asks Trump to Repeal Major Climate Policies
- More than 1 billion young people could be at risk of hearing loss, a new study shows
- IRS says $1.5 billion in tax refunds remain unclaimed. Here's what to know.
- Trump Wants to Erase Protections in Alaska’s Tongass National Forest, a Storehouse of Carbon
Recommendation
-
Republican Gabe Evans ousts Democratic US Rep. Yadira Caraveo in Colorado
-
Celebrated Water Program That Examined Fracking, Oil Sands Is Abruptly Shut Down
-
Food insecurity is driving women in Africa into sex work, increasing HIV risk
-
South Carolina officer rescues woman mouthing help me during traffic stop
-
Reds honor Pete Rose with a 14-hour visitation at Great American Ball Park
-
Today’s Climate: August 6, 2010
-
Michigan voters approve amendment adding reproductive rights to state constitution
-
Meeting abortion patients where they are: providers turn to mobile units