Current:Home > BackToo Cozy with Coal? Group Charges Feds Are Rubber-Stamping Mine Approvals-LoTradeCoin
Too Cozy with Coal? Group Charges Feds Are Rubber-Stamping Mine Approvals
View Date:2025-01-11 10:25:25
Environmental advocates are suing federal officials, alleging they approved the expansion of four Western coal mines on public lands without adequately taking their climate impacts into account.
The New Mexico-based group WildEarth Guardians is accusing the U.S. Department of the Interior of rubber-stamping coal mine expansions in Colorado, New Mexico and Wyoming without comprehensive environmental reviews, according to a lawsuit filed Sept. 15 in the U.S. District Court of Colorado. The Interior department oversees the leasing of public lands for fossil fuel extraction.
“We are seeing a disturbing pattern in the Interior Department, where every time they review a mining approval or a lease, they always come to the same conclusion: the carbon impacts are insignificant,” said Jeremy Nichols, climate and energy program director at WildEarth Guardians. “This is absolutely insane.”
In the official complaint, WildEarth Guardians argues that the review process used by the Interior Department is flawed. The climate impacts of individual mining approvals are considered in isolation, but “they should be taking into account the cumulative impact of all federal coal leasing and mining decisions” during these reviews, Nichols said, citing the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA).
The carbon footprint for the entire coal program—which accounts for 40 percent of the coal produced in the U.S.—is significant. In 2012, the federal coal program’s greenhouse gas footprint was equivalent to the annual emissions of more than 161 million cars on the road, according to a Center for American Progress report published in March.
The Supply Side of Pollution
Despite the federal coal program’s major carbon footprint, it has so far faced little pressure by the Obama administration. While President Barack Obama has taken many steps to curb the so-called demand side of climate pollution, including reducing power plant emissions with the Clean Power Plan, said Ted Zukoski, an attorney at the nonprofit legal group Earthjustice, he has “turned a blind eye” to the supply side of the pollution, including the coal leasing program.
The Interior Department recently began discussing how to update the federal coal program, hosting a series of public listening sessions across the country this summer. WildEarth Guardians, among other environmental groups, participated in the sessions. This year the agency proposed changes to how royalties for coal are calculated as well as a new rule to better protect community water sources for coal mining; it is unclear whether any additional new rules are being contemplated.
The four mines targeted in the lawsuit—Colorado’s Bowie No. 2 mine, New Mexico’s El Segundo mine, and Wyoming’s Antelope and Black Thunder mines—produce more than 240 million tons of coal per year.
According to WildEarth Guardians’ analyses, the lifespans of these coal mines will be extended from three to 21 years because of the expansions approved between November 2013 and April 2015.
The environmental activists reviewed the applications for the mines’ expansions and identified similar problems in each—such as incomplete climate impact analyses and a lack of public involvement during the review process.
Carbon-Cost Accounting
Nichols said that there are two main ways regulators can strengthen reviews. First, they should be taking the cumulative climate impacts of the entire program into account. Second, he said, officials should use a government-sanctioned “social cost of carbon” tool to calculate the amount society will pay for the harm caused by each ton of carbon dioxide added to the atmosphere by the project.
Chris Holmes, a spokesman for the Department of the Interior, told InsideClimate News in an email that the agency does not comment on pending litigation.
Last July, WildEarth Guardians brought a successful lawsuit that halted the development of a federal coal lease in Colorado. According to Judge R. Brooke Jackson’s ruling, officials should have considered the global-warming costs associated with the project in addition to the supposed economic benefits during the review.
The energy companies had varying reactions to WildEarth Guardians’ latest lawsuit.
Cloud Peak Energy, the operator of Antelope mine, and Peabody Natural Resources Company, the operator of El Segundo mine, both defended their mines to InsideClimate News.
“Antelope mine’s federal coal leases and mining operations were thoroughly evaluated” in a process that included environmental evaluation and opportunities for public comment, said Rick Curtsinger from Cloud Peak Energy, owner of the subsidiary Antelope Coal LLC.
“The El Segundo mine plan was thoroughly vetted, and its approval was granted in accordance with all applicable laws,” said a Peabody spokesman.
The operators of Bowie No. 2 mine and Black Thunder mine both declined to comment.
WildEarth Guardians has filed similar lawsuits against the Interior Department relating to coal leases and coal mine expansions, with varying success. At least two cases relating to mines in Montana and New Mexico are ongoing.
The overarching goal of this case—and others—is to force regulators to be more transparent and thorough in their future management of coal leases.
“I think one of the things WildEarth Guardians is trying to do with this litigation … is to train the agencies that they have a duty to disclose climate impacts of things like coal mines,” said Zukoski.
veryGood! (93811)
Related
- Threat closes Spokane City Hall and cancels council meeting in Washington state
- Somber bugles and bells mark Armistice Day around the globe as wars drown out peace messages
- Why Spain’s acting leader is offering a politically explosive amnesty for Catalan separatists
- Cuffing season has arrived. Don't jump into a relationship just because it's here.
- Tuskegee University closes its campus to the public, fires security chief after shooting
- AP PHOTOS: Anxiety, grief and despair grip Gaza and Israel on week 5 of the Israel-Hamas war
- Kelsea Ballerini and Chase Stokes Deserve an Award for Their Sweet Reaction to Her 2024 Grammy Nomination
- How researchers, farmers and brewers want to safeguard beer against climate change
- Wildfires burn from coast-to-coast; red flag warnings issued for Northeast
- What the Melting of Antarctic Ice Shelves Means for the Planet
Ranking
- 2025 NFL mock draft: QBs Shedeur Sanders, Cam Ward crack top five
- Lyrics can be used as evidence during rapper Young Thug's trial on gang and racketeering charges, judge rules
- Colorado star Shedeur Sanders is nation's most-sacked QB. Painkillers may be his best blockers.
- ‘From the river to the sea': Why these 6 words spark fury and passion over the Israel-Hamas war
- Patricia Heaton criticizes media, 'extremists' she says 'fear-mongered' in 2024 election
- Astronaut Frank Borman, commander of the first Apollo mission to the moon, has died at age 95
- The Taylor Swift reporter can come to the phone right now: Ask him anything on Instagram
- The 4-day workweek: How one Ohio manufacturer is making it work
Recommendation
-
Suspected shooter and four others are found dead in three Kansas homes, police say
-
‘Nope’ star Keke Palmer alleges physical abuse by ex-boyfriend Darius Jackson, court documents say
-
Who’s running for president? See a rundown of the 2024 candidates
-
Pakistani police cracking down on migrants are arresting Afghan women and children, activists claim
-
How Alex Jones’ Infowars wound up in the hands of The Onion
-
Siemens Gamesa scraps plans to build blades for offshore wind turbines on Virginia’s coast
-
Kansas City to hire 2 overdose investigators in face of rising fentanyl deaths
-
Let's Take a Moment to Appreciate Every Lavish Detail of Paris Hilton's 3-Day Wedding