Current:Home > NewsSouth Carolina’s top public health doctor warns senators wrong lessons being learned from COVID-LoTradeCoin
South Carolina’s top public health doctor warns senators wrong lessons being learned from COVID
View Date:2024-12-24 00:32:01
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — South Carolina’s top doctor came before a small group of state senators on Thursday to tell them he thinks a bill overhauling how public health emergencies are handled in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic has some bad ideas, concerns echoed by Gov. Henry McMaster.
As drafted, the bill would prevent mandating vaccines unless they have been licensed by the Food and Drug Administration for 10 years. That means that health care providers would be blocked from requiring flu vaccines or other shots that get yearly updates for ever-changing viruses, said Dr. Edward Simmer, director of the state Department of Health and Environmental Control.
In addition to loosening restrictions on who can visit people in isolation, the measure would also require symptom-free patients to be released from quarantine well before some infectious diseases begin to show outward signs, Simmer said at a Thursday hearing.
“There are a number of issues that we believe where this bill would cause harm to the people of South Carolina and would in fact cause unnecessary death amongst people of South Carolina during a public health crisis because it would prevent us from taking actions that could save lives,” Simmer said.
The bill passed the Senate subcommittee on a 4-3 vote, but with eight weeks to go in the General Assembly’s session, it still has to get through the body’s Medical Affairs Committee and a vote on the Senate floor before it can even be sent to the House.
In a further sign of the hurdles the bill faces, McMaster sent the subcommittee a letter saying “placing overbroad restrictions on the authority of public health officials, law enforcement officers, first responders, and emergency management professionals responding to emerging threats and disasters—whether public health or otherwise — is a bad idea.”
A similar subcommittee met in September, where many speakers sewed doubt about vaccine safety and efficacy, as well as distrust in the scientific establishment.
Members on Thursday listened to Simmer and took up some amendments on his concern and promised to discuss his other worries with the bill.
“You are making some good points, Dr. Simmer. I’m writing them all down,” Republican Sen. Richard Cash of Powdersville said.
The proposal would require health officials to release someone from quarantine if they didn’t show symptoms for five days. Simmers said people with diseases like measles, meningitis, bird flu and Ebola are contagious, but may not show symptoms for a week or more.
“I don’t think we would want after 10 days to release a person known to be infected with Ebola into the public,” Simmer said.
Supporters of the bill said they weren’t happy that during the start of the COVID-19 pandemic hospitals and nursing homes put patients into isolation. Allowing quicker releases from isolation and letting more people to visit someone in quarantine was a response to that issue.
Cash told Simmer that when the pandemic shutdown started, his wife had just endured a 17-hour cancer surgery and he was ordered to leave her bedside.
“Whatever she’s got, I got. But I still had to go,” Cash said.
Simmer said those decisions were made by the private nursing homes, hospitals and health care facilities. He said he had sympathy for decisions that had to be made quickly without much data, but he thought they were still wrong and pointed out the state didn’t order anyone to take a vaccine or isolate entire facilities.
“We saw the pictures of people seeing nursing home patients through a window. They should have been allowed in,” Simmer said. “When that didn’t happen that was a mistake. That was a lesson learned from COVID.”
Simmer asked lawmakers to pay attention to what actually happened during the pandemic and not just what they think happened.
“If this bill is designed to address concerns about COVID, we should recognize what did and did not happen during the pandemic,” Simmer said.
veryGood! (51)
Related
- The USDA is testing raw milk for the avian flu. Is raw milk safe?
- K-9 dog dies after being in patrol car with broken air conditioning, police say
- This Nigerian city has a high birth rate of twins — and no one is sure why
- Hawaii's Kilauea volcano erupts as volcanic glass fragments and ash fall on Big Island
- Social media star squirrel euthanized after being taken from home tests negative for rabies
- John Hickenlooper on Climate Change: Where the Candidate Stands
- Dianna Agron Addresses Past Fan Speculation About Her and Taylor Swift's Friendship
- Unemployment aid applications jump to highest level since October 2021
- Moana 2 Star Dwayne Johnson Shares the Empowering Message Film Sends to Young Girls
- Uganda has locked down two districts in a bid to stem the spread of Ebola
Ranking
- Conviction and 7-year sentence for Alex Murdaugh’s banker overturned in appeal of juror’s dismissal
- Today’s Climate: July 31 – Aug. 1, 2010
- Today’s Climate: July 19, 2010
- Prince Harry's Spare Ghostwriter Recalls Shouting at Him Amid Difficult Edits
- NASCAR Championship race live updates, how to watch: Cup title on the line at Phoenix
- Save $423 on an HP Laptop and Get 1 Year of Microsoft Office and Wireless Mouse for Free
- Millions of Americans are losing access to maternal care. Here's what can be done
- Selling Sunset's Jason Oppenheim Teases Intense New Season, Plus the Items He Can't Live Without
Recommendation
-
Ford agrees to pay up to $165 million penalty to US government for moving too slowly on recalls
-
I always avoided family duties. Then my dad had a fall and everything changed
-
24 Mother’s Day Gifts From Amazon That Look Way More Expensive Than They Actually Are
-
Children's hospitals grapple with a nationwide surge in RSV infections
-
'Gladiator 2' review: Yes, we are entertained again by outrageous sequel
-
What’s Eating Away at the Greenland Ice Sheet?
-
Bryan Miller, Phoenix man dubbed The Zombie Hunter, sentenced to death for 1990s murders of Angela Brosso and Melanie Bernas
-
Keystone I Leak Raises More Doubts About Pipeline Safety