Current:Home > MyNCAA's proposed $2.8 billion settlement with athletes runs into trouble with federal judge-LoTradeCoin
NCAA's proposed $2.8 billion settlement with athletes runs into trouble with federal judge
View Date:2024-12-23 20:19:43
A federal judge in California said Thursday she will not grant preliminary approval to the current version of a proposed multi-billion-dollar settlement of three athlete compensation antitrust cases against the NCAA and the Power Five conferences.
Following a 2½-hour remote hearing, U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken and lawyers for the sides agreed that the parties would get back to her in three weeks with what she termed a "prognosis" for the proposed deal.
While Wilken said "it seems likely enough there will be a settlement," she also raised the prospect that the lawyers may come back to her and "say … give us a trial date."
The NCAA’s lead attorney during Thursday’s hearing, Rakesh Kilaru, said during the session that given Wilken’s concerns, he and the plaintiffs’ lawyers "have to talk about whether we have a deal to talk about."
In addition to providing a nearly $2.8 billion damages pool for current and former athletes over a span of 10 years, the proposed deal would allow Division I schools to start paying athletes directly for use of their name, image and likeness (NIL), subject to a per-school cap that would increase over time.
But the deal also would attempt to bring NIL payments under some enforceable rules, and Wilken said during the hearing she has issues with the proposed regulations, calling them "quite strict" and questioning whether they would end up in athletes losing access to payments they have been receiving from collectives.
"Taking things away from people doesn’t work well," she remarked.
Wilken also questioned the legality of a deal that, because of its length, stands to impact the rights of future athletes who are far from college age – "the 6-year-old playing kickball on the asphalt,” as she put it. She wondered who would represent future classes of incoming classes of athletes who would be largely bound by the proposed settlement, and whether it was appropriate for the current plaintiffs’ attorneys to do that without them facing significant a conflict of interest due to their connection to this proposed deal.
The NCAA said in a statement Thursday night: “The settlement agreement the NCAA and autonomy conferences submitted to the court was the product of hard-fought negotiations that would bring stability and sustainability to college sports … That continues to be our goal and the NCAA and autonomy conferences will carefully consider the court’s questions, which are not uncommon in the context of class action settlements.”
However, Thursday’s developments unsettled some in the major-college sports community – especially Wilken’s concern with the proposed regulatory process, which the NCAA considers to be critical to a settlement. Kilaru, the NCAA’s attorney, stressed that association’s position is that pay for play is prohibited under NCAA rules – and that prohibition has been upheld by various courts.
Under the settlement, athletes would have to report NIL payments of more than $600 to a clearinghouse that would be established. And their deals would be subject to review, with the goal being the prevention of pay for play and deals that pay amounts above market value.
Athletes who have questions about the permissibility of their agreements would be able to seek advisory opinion from an enforcement group. If the enforcement group sought to sanction an athlete because of a deal, the athlete would have the ability to bring the matter to an arbitrator.
Wilken’s concerns about this "is a potential killer," said a source familiar with the process who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the case. "I haven’t seen all of it yet, but it doesn’t sound good, that’s for sure."
Wilken raised questions with how a booster providing pay for play would be defined under the proposed setup.
"Today’s third-party donor" to a collective "is tomorrow’s booster. Now they can’t do it anymore …
"What if Mr. Fan gives them a million dollars or gives them all a truck. Is that a booster? I don’t know. Is that a collective? I don’t know. Is having a winning team a valid business purpose?"
On several occasions she jousted directly with Kilaru, the NCAA attorney.
Discussing the prospect of schools directly paying athletes amounts, at their discretion within the cap, for their NIL, Wilken asked Kilaru: "That wouldn’t be pay for play?"
Kilaru: "No, Your Honor."
Wilken ultimately said to all of the attorneys: "I turn this back on you all to" find something "workable, consistent … enforceable and fair."
Steve Berman, a lead attorney for the plaintiffs told USA TODAY Sports on Thursday night that Wilken having concerns is "not totally unexpected. … We’ll try to negotiate something. I don’t think it’s all that hard. … And it’s not in (the NCAA’s) interest to stick their heads in the sand and face the consequences of continued litigation."
Contributing: Matt Hayes, USA TODAY Network
veryGood! (3)
Related
- Mason Bates’ Met-bound opera ‘Kavalier & Clay’ based on Michael Chabon novel premieres in Indiana
- 'Futurama' Season 12: Premiere date, episode schedule, where to watch
- American Morelle McCane endured death of her brother during long road to Olympics
- Watch this soldier's shocked grandparents scream with joy over his unexpected visit
- Jenn Tran's Ex Devin Strader Throws Shade At Her DWTS Partner Sasha Farber Amid Romance Rumors
- Who plays Deadpool, Wolverine and Ladypool in 'Deadpool and Wolverine'? See full cast
- Thousands battle Western wildfires as smoke puts millions under air quality alerts
- American Morelle McCane endured death of her brother during long road to Olympics
- NFL Week 11 picks straight up and against spread: Will Bills hand Chiefs first loss of season?
- Packers QB Jordan Love ties record for NFL's highest-paid player with massive contract
Ranking
- Diamond Sports Group can emerge out of bankruptcy after having reorganization plan approved
- Why Olympian Jordan Chiles Almost Quit Gymnastics
- Beyoncé introduces Team USA during NBC coverage of Paris Olympics opening ceremony: Watch
- Paris Olympics highlights: USA wins first gold medal, Katie Ledecky gets bronze Saturday
- Hurricane-stricken Tampa Bay Rays to play 2025 season at Yankees’ spring training field in Tampa
- One Extraordinary Photo: Charlie Riedel captures Simone Biles in flight at the Paris Games
- Pilot dead after helicopter crashed in upstate New York
- California Still Has No Plan to Phase Out Oil Refineries
Recommendation
-
'Gladiator 2' review: Yes, we are entertained again by outrageous sequel
-
Why Alyssa Thomas’ Olympic debut for USA Basketball is so special: 'Really proud of her'
-
Pilot dead after helicopter crashed in upstate New York
-
UFC 304 live results: Early prelims underway; match card, what to know
-
QTM Community Introduce
-
Firefighters helped by cooler weather battle blaze that has scorched area size of Los Angeles
-
Maine launches investigation after 2 escape youth center, steal car
-
Can tech help solve the Los Angeles homeless crisis? Finding shelter may someday be a click away