Current:Home > MarketsOxford school shooter's mom won't have affair used against her in trial-LoTradeCoin
Oxford school shooter's mom won't have affair used against her in trial
View Date:2024-12-23 19:55:33
A Michigan judge has decided not to consider the affairs the mother of the Oxford school shooter had in her and her husband's upcoming trial as the first parents in the U.S. charged in a mass shooting.
Jennifer and James Crumbley are due in court Wednesday, days after their son, Ethan, was sentenced to life in prison.
The judge in the case also said evidence of Ethan Crumbley's bird-torturing hobby, including storing a bird's head in a jar under his bed, will be inadmissible in the trial against his parents.
Oakland County Circuit Judge Cheryl Matthews held that the so-called "bird evidence" is irrelevant, but noted that "even if it were relevant, it is unfairly prejudicial."
Prosecutors had hoped to use the "bird evidence" against Jennifer Crumbley, who along with her husband, have separate trials on involuntary manslaughter charges for buying their son, Ethan, the gun that he used in the massacre and not disclosing that to the school when they had the chance to.
Four students were killed in the shooting. Six others and a teacher were also injured.
Mom's knowledge of troubled son's bird behavior
From the start, prosecutors have laid much blame for the tragedy on the Crumbleys, portraying them as selfish parents who cared more about their horses and getting drunk than taking care of their troubled son. Specifically, prosecutors allege the parents ignored a child who was spiraling out of control and hallucinating, and instead of getting him help, they bought him a gun, which he used to carry out the Nov. 30, 2021, massacre.
As for the bird evidence, the prosecution disclosed new details about Jennifer Crumbley's knowledge of her son's bird interest. For example, on May 3, 2021, Ethan Crumbley took a picture of an unmutilated bird and posted it on his Instagram page with the following text: "How do you do fellow bird."
A month later, his mom responded "Dead," with an emoji of a person with hands raised up.
Similar pictures of the same bird and a nest were found on Jennifer Crumbley's phone, the prosecution wrote in a Dec. 7 filing, arguing the jury needs to see a "complete picture" of the bird evidence at the mother's trial. The prosecution also wanted jurors to know about the photograph of a bird's head in a jar that Ethan Crumbley took on May 15, 2021.
But the judge said no, granting the wish of the defense, which previously argued:
"The 'bird evidence' is so extremely disgusting, sickening and appalling that its admission would certainly inflame the passions of a jury. The jury will undoubtedly judge Mrs. Crumbley for the heinous acts of her son, which she knew nothing about," defense attorney Shannon Smith wrote in a previous filing.
Evidence that will and won't be allowed
Smith also expressed concern about prosecutors bringing forward an alleged affair the mother was involved in when Ethan was 6 years old.
The judge concluded no affairs would be admissable as evidence. The judge is also not allowing in trial any mention of the parents' messy house, alcohol and marijuana use in the home, their son's internet searches and a Nazi coin he kept.
But the judge will allow evidence about the time and money the Crumbleys spent on horseback riding and their son playing violent video games.
More recently, the judge also admitted as evidence an Instagram account by Ethan Crumbley that his mom followed.
While the shooter kept multiple Instagram accounts, one included a photo of the gun his dad bought him during a Black Friday shopping trip in 2021, just four days before the shooting.
After getting his gun, Ethan Crumbley took photos of it and posted it to Instagram, writing: "Just got my new beauty today. Sig Sauer 9 mm."
His mom had access to that account.
Four days later, after his parents were summoned to his school over a troubling drawing he had made in math class, Ethan Crumbley emerged from a bathroom and opened fire with his new gun.
The prosecution argues that the Crumbleys, more than anyone else, could have prevented the shooting had they disclosed to the school that they had bought their son a gun days earlier. But they withheld that information after being shown a drawing their son had made of a gun, a bleeding body, and the words, "The Thoughts won't stop, help me." The couple asked whether their son could be returned to class, went back to their jobs, and promised to get their son help in the coming days.
The Crumbleys maintain they had no way of knowing their son would carry out a school shooting, and that the gun at issue was safely stored.
Ethan Crumbley pleaded guilty to all charges
Ethan Crumbley, who was 15 years old when he carried out the shooting and later pleaded guilty to all the charges, did not ask for leniency at his sentencing last week. Rather, he told the judge to give the victims what they asked for, and that only he — no one else — was responsible for the tragedy.
The teenage killer also made a disclosure that could help his parents, whom prosecutors say engaged in gross negligence that contributed to the deaths of the four slain students.
"We are all here because of me today, what I did ... I could not stop myself," Crumbley told the judge at sentencing. "My parents did not know what I planned to do. They are not at fault."
veryGood! (391)
Related
- Jamie Lee Curtis and Don Lemon quit X, formerly Twitter: 'Time for me to leave'
- Jon Lovett, 'Pod Save America' host and former Obama speechwriter, joins 'Survivor'
- The Extravagant Way Cher and Boyfriend Alexander Edwards Celebrated Her 78th Birthday
- Arizona man convicted of first-degree murder in starvation death of 6-year-old son
- Queen Bey and Yale: The Ivy League university is set to offer a course on Beyoncé and her legacy
- Angelina Jolie Ordered to Turn Over 8 Years’ Worth of NDAs in Brad Pitt Winery Lawsuit
- See Michael Keaton, Jenna Ortega get their spooky on in 'Beetlejuice Beetlejuice' trailer
- UCLA's police chief 'reassigned temporarily' after campus protests on Israel-Hamas war
- DWTS' Gleb Savchenko Shares Why He Ended Brooks Nader Romance Through Text Message
- Why Robert Downey Jr. Calls Chris Hemsworth the Second-Best Chris
Ranking
- Congress returns to unfinished business and a new Trump era
- North Carolina Governor Roy Cooper vetoes first bill of 2024 legislative session
- Explorers discover possible wreckage of World War II ace Richard Bong’s plane in South Pacific
- NFL legend Warrick Dunn's housing program changes lives of single parents
- 'Heretic' spoilers! Hugh Grant spills on his horror villain's fears and fate
- Bursting can of bear spray drove away grizzly in Teton attack; bear won't be killed: Reports
- Most Jersey Shore beaches are in good shape as summer starts, but serious erosion a problem in spots
- Minneapolis to host WWE SummerSlam 2026 — and it will be a two-day event for the first time
Recommendation
-
South Carolina to take a break from executions for the holidays
-
Save 20% on This Tatcha Moisturizer I’ve Used Since Kathy Hilton Sprayed It on Real Housewives
-
Charles Barkley says WNBA players are being 'petty' over attention paid to Caitlin Clark
-
Here's the full list of hurricane names for the 2024 season
-
Eva Longoria calls US 'dystopian' under Trump, has moved with husband and son
-
Get 50% Off Old Navy, 60% Off Fenty Beauty, 70% Off Anthropologie, 70% Off Madewell & Memorial Day Deals
-
Dashcam video shows Scottie Scheffler's arrest; officials say detective who detained golf star violated bodycam policy
-
Caitlin Clark should listen to Jewell Loyd. Fellow top pick's advice could turn around rookie year.