Current:Home > ScamsPennsylvania’s long-running dispute over dates on mail-in voting ballots is back in the courts-LoTradeCoin
Pennsylvania’s long-running dispute over dates on mail-in voting ballots is back in the courts
View Date:2024-12-23 16:57:22
HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — A technical requirement that Pennsylvania voters write accurate dates on the exterior envelope of mail-in ballots was again the subject of a court proceeding on Thursday as advocates argued the mandate unfairly leads to otherwise valid votes being thrown out.
A five-judge Commonwealth Court panel heard about two hours of argument in a case that was filed in May, even though the date requirement has been upheld both by the state Supreme Court and the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
The case was brought by the Black Political Empowerment Project, Common Cause and allied advocacy groups against the secretary of state and the elections boards in Philadelphia and Allegheny County, which includes Pittsburgh. They argued that enforcing the date requirement infringes upon voting rights and that none of the prior cases on the topic directly ruled whether it runs afoul of the state constitution’s Free and Equal Elections Clause.
The number of potentially invalid ballots at stake is a small fraction of the electorate, in the range of 10,000 or more across Pennsylvania in prior elections, and those voters tend to be comparatively older. Democrats have embraced voting by mail much more than Republicans since it was widely expanded in Pennsylvania in 2019 — months before the COVID-19 pandemic — as part of a legislative deal in which Democrats got universal mail-in voting while GOP lawmakers obtained an end to straight-ticket voting by party.
More than a third of ballots cast in this year’s state primary election were by mail, according to the lawsuit.
Judge Patricia McCullough, a Republican on the panel, asked what authority Commonwealth Court has over the legislatively enacted rule.
“Can this court just come in and change the law because it wasn’t the best thing they should have written or we don’t think it has a purpose? Is that a grounds for us to change or declare something to be invalid?” she asked.
John M. Gore, a lawyer for the state and national Republican Party groups that are fighting the lawsuit, said the court would only have grounds to do so if the procedure was “so difficult as to deny the franchise.” He argued to the judges that the dating requirement is not so onerous that it denies people the right to vote.
The dates serve as a backstop, Gore said, providing evidence about when ballots were completed and submitted. The mandate also “drives home the solemnity of the voter’s choice” to vote by mail, and could help deter and detect fraud, he said.
What to know about the 2024 Election
- Democracy: American democracy has overcome big stress tests since 2020. More challenges lie ahead in 2024.
- AP’s Role: The Associated Press is the most trusted source of information on election night, with a history of accuracy dating to 1848. Learn more.
- Stay informed. Keep your pulse on the news with breaking news email alerts. Sign up here.
County elections officials say they do not use the handwritten envelope dates to determine whether mail-in votes have been submitted in time. Mail-in ballots are generally postmarked, elections officials process and time-stamp them, and the presence of the ballots themselves is enough evidence to show that they arrived on time to be counted before the 8 p.m. Election Day deadline.
Among the issues before the court panel is whether throwing out a portion of the 2019 voting law would trigger a provision under which the entire law must also be thrown out.
Mail-in ballots, and the dating requirement in particular, have spawned several legal cases in Pennsylvania in recent years. Earlier this year, the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the mandate for accurate, handwritten dates, overturning a district judge’s decision.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled two years ago that mail-in votes may not count if they are “contained in undated or incorrectly dated outer envelopes.” The justices had split 3-3 on whether making the envelope dates mandatory under state law would violate provisions of the U.S. Civil Rights Act of 1964, which states that immaterial errors or omissions should not be used to prevent voting.
During the April primary, redesigned exterior envelopes reduced the rate of rejected ballots, according to state elections officials.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- Dwayne Johnson Admits to Peeing in Bottles on Set After Behavior Controversy
- 3 exhumed Tulsa Race Massacre victims found with gunshot wounds
- Powell may use Jackson Hole speech to hint at how fast and how far the Fed could cut rates
- Taylor Swift finally sings long awaited 'Reputation' track
- Georgia House Republicans stick with leadership team for the next two years
- Khadijah Haqq's Ex Bobby McCray Files for Divorce One Year She Announces Breakup
- Taylor Swift, who can decode you? Fans will try as they look for clues for 'Reputation TV'
- Charlie Sheen's Twin Sons Bob and Max Make Rare Appearance With Mom Brooke Mueller
- Former West Virginia jail officer pleads guilty to civil rights violation in fatal assault on inmate
- ABC News names longtime producer Karamehmedovic as network news division chief
Ranking
- New York nursing home operator accused of neglect settles with state for $45M
- Olympian Noah Lyles Defends Girlfriend Junelle Bromfield Against “Pure Disrespect and Hatred”
- East Palestine residents want more time and information before deciding to accept $600M settlement
- A muscle car that time forgot? Revisiting the 1973 Pontiac GTO Colonnade
- Research reveals China has built prototype nuclear reactor to power aircraft carrier
- ABC News names longtime producer Karamehmedovic as network news division chief
- GOP-led challenge to voting by mail rejected by New York’s top court
- Horoscopes Today, August 18, 2024
Recommendation
-
Younghoo Koo takes blame for Falcons loss to Saints: 'This game is fully on me'
-
Value meal wars heat up as more fast food spots, restaurants offer discounted menu items
-
PHOTO COLLECTION: AP Top Photos of the Day Monday August 19, 2024
-
US settles with billionaire Carl Icahn for using company to secure personal loans worth billions
-
Lions find way to win, Bears in tough spot: Best (and worst) from NFL Week 10
-
'We've lost a hero': Georgia deputy fatally shot after responding to domestic dispute
-
Mamie Laverock Leaves Hospital 3 Months After Falling Off Five-Story Balcony
-
California hits milestones toward 100% clean energy — but has a long way to go