Current:Home > FinanceMinnesota professor dismissed over showing Islamic art can proceed with lawsuit, judge rules-LoTradeCoin
Minnesota professor dismissed over showing Islamic art can proceed with lawsuit, judge rules
View Date:2024-12-23 20:32:18
ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — A former Hamline University adjunct art professor can proceed with her lawsuit against the private Minnesota school but only on the basis of religious discrimination, a federal judge has ruled.
Erika López Prater sued Hamline University earlier this year after she was dismissed following a complaint from a Muslim student that she showed ancient images of the Prophet Muhammad in a global art course last year.
U.S. District Judge Katherine Menendez on Friday dismissed several other claims in López Prater’s lawsuit, including those claiming reprisal, defamation, intentional infliction of emotional distress and retaliation, the Star Tribune of Minneapolis reported. López Prater’s attorney has argued that the school would have treated her differently if she were Muslim.
The judge noted that López Prater’s religious discrimination argument is novel and that it will likely be hard to show that the university would have treated her differently if she were Muslim. Nevertheless, she rejected Hamline University’s request to dismiss the claim entirely.
The controversy began in October when López Prater showed a 14th-century painting depicting the Prophet Muhammad to her students as part of a lesson on Islamic art. She had warned them beforehand in the class syllabus, giving them an opportunity to opt out. She also reportedly gave a trigger warning before the lesson in which the image was shown. A student who attended the class — who was president of Hamline’s Muslim Student Association — complained to the university, saying the trigger warning didn’t define what image would be shown. In Islam, portraying the Prophet Muhammad has long been taboo for many.
The university later decided not to renew López Prater’s contract.
The fallout was far-reaching, leading the school’s faculty to overwhelmingly call for university President Fayneese Miller to resign. Miller announced in April that she will retire next year. That announcement came three months after she conceded that she mishandled the situation, particularly in calling López Prater’s showing of the image “Islamophobic.”
An attorney for the university, Mark Berhow, said he and the school’s legal team are encouraged by the judge’s decision to dismiss most claims and “look forward to demonstrating that the sole remaining claim is also without merit.”
veryGood! (75194)
Related
- Black and Latino families displaced from Palm Springs neighborhood reach $27M tentative settlement
- Transgender patients sue the hospital that provided their records to Tennessee’s attorney general
- U.S. consumer confidence jumps to a two-year high as inflation eases
- Serving house music history with Honey Dijon
- Judge moves to slash $38 million verdict in New Hampshire youth center abuse case
- Harvey Weinstein found guilty on 3 of 7 charges in Los Angeles
- Actor Jeremy Renner undergoes surgery after suffering from a snow plow accident
- US air quality today: Maps show Chicago, Minneapolis among cities impacted by Canadian wildfire smoke
- Guns smuggled from the US are blamed for a surge in killings on more Caribbean islands
- Defense wants Pittsburgh synagogue shooter’s long-dead father exhumed to prove paternity
Ranking
- Gisele Bündchen Makes First Major Appearance Since Pregnancy
- Three found dead at campsite were members of Colorado Springs family who planned to live ‘off grid’
- Education Department opens investigation into Harvard’s legacy admissions
- What's making us happy: A guide to your weekend reading and viewing.
- The Fate of Hoda Kotb and Jenna Bush Hager's Today Fourth Hour Revealed
- Shop Summer Essentials at the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale 2023 for Sandals, Sunglasses, Shorts & More
- 'Reservation Dogs' co-creator says the show gives audiences permission to laugh
- Sister of Carlee Russell's Ex-Boyfriend Weighs In on Stupid as Hell Kidnapping Hoax
Recommendation
-
Reese Witherspoon's Daughter Ava Phillippe Introduces Adorable New Family Member
-
UPS reaches tentative contract with 340,000 unionized workers, potentially dodging calamitous strike
-
Iran releases a top actress who was held for criticizing the crackdown on protests
-
What's making us happy: A guide to your weekend reading and viewing.
-
Why Outer Banks Fans Think Costars Rudy Pankow and Madison Bailey Used Stunt Doubles Amid Rumored Rift
-
Harvey Weinstein found guilty on 3 of 7 charges in Los Angeles
-
Flight delays, cancellations could continue for a decade amid airline workforce shortage
-
North Korea stonewalls US on status of detained soldier