Current:Home > FinanceNew Mexico Supreme Court reprimands judge who advised prosecutors in case involving his daughter-LoTradeCoin
New Mexico Supreme Court reprimands judge who advised prosecutors in case involving his daughter
View Date:2024-12-23 19:34:53
SANTA FE, N.M. (AP) — The New Mexico Supreme Court has publicly censured a state judge in Las Cruces with for providing advice to prosecutors during a 2021 trial of a man accused of pointing an assault rifle at the judge’s daughter.
Third District Judge James Martin also was censured for allowing his daughter to wait in his chambers before she testified at the trial — which another judge presided over — and for having an inappropriate conversation with the prosecutors after Robert Burnham was convicted of aggravated assault by use of a firearm.
Martin accepted the court’s decision, the Supreme Court said. It said Martin “denied committing willful misconduct” but “viewed through the lens of hindsight ... recognizes the potential for appearance of impropriety based upon his conduct.”
The justices said their decision reached Nov. 13 was not selected for publication in the formal New Mexico Appellate Records. But it was made public this week and will be published in the New Mexico Bar Bulletin.
Martin did not immediately respond Thursday to The Associated Press’ requests for comment sent in an email and left in a telephone message at his office at the court, which was closed for the holiday.
Burnham is appealing the conviction stemming from the 2018 incident outside a Las Cruces bar he owned. He told police that he had recently won the rifle in a raffle and was just moving it inside his car.
The Supreme Court said after the first day of the two-day jury trial in 2021 before Third District Judge Steven Blankinship that Martin telephoned Assistant District Attorney Samuel Rosten and told him he should use the term “brandished a firearm” in his jury instructions instead of “pointed a firearm” at the alleged victim, Martin’s daughter.
The next day the prosecution followed that advice.
Following the conviction, Martin inquired as to whether Burnham had been remanded to custody while awaiting sentencing. When Martin learned that he had, he told the prosecutors, “Good thing he was remanded, otherwise I would have told you to go back in there and try again.”
Martin improperly allowed his daughter to be present for that conversation. He also improperly allowed his daughter to wait in his chambers down the hall while waiting to be called as a witness at the trial, the high court said.
The justices said Martin originally provided advice to the prosecutors because he recognized a legitimate mistake of law in their proposed jury instructions.
“Judge Martin believed that he was acting in his daughter’s best interest by pointing out the mistake. Judge Martin’s actions created an appearance of impropriety, which should not be ignored,” Chief Justice C. Shannon Bacon wrote in the decision joined by the four other justices.
“We issue this censure not only to remind judges of their responsibility to avoid the appearance of impropriety but also to ensure the public that our legal system is committed to maintaining an independent, fair and impartial judiciary under the law,” they said.
veryGood! (65)
Related
- Sofia Richie Reveals 5-Month-Old Daughter Eloise Has a Real Phone
- Man sentenced to death for arson attack at Japanese anime studio that killed 36
- What's next for Eagles? Nick Sirianni out to 'reprove' himself; GM defends Jalen Hurts
- Experimental gene therapy allows kids with inherited deafness to hear
- Inspector general finds no fault in Park Police shooting of Virginia man in 2017
- Oscar nominations 2024 snubs and surprises: No best director nominations for Bradley Cooper, Greta Gerwig
- Nevada judge approves signature-gathering stage for petition to put abortion rights on 2024 ballot
- He paid Virgin Galactic $200,000 for a few minutes in space. The trip left him speechless.
- Ben Affleck and His Son Samuel, 12, Enjoy a Rare Night Out Together
- Elle King Postpones Concert After Dolly Parton Tribute Incident
Ranking
- Eva Longoria calls US 'dystopian' under Trump, has moved with husband and son
- Danny Masterson denied bail, judge says actor has 'every incentive to flee': Reports
- In-N-Out to close Oakland, California restaurant due to wave of car break-ins, armed robberies
- Housing is now unaffordable for a record half of all U.S. renters, study finds
- After Baltimore mass shooting, neighborhood goes full year with no homicides
- Fans raise $260,000 for cat adoption charity in honor of Buffalo Bills kicker Tyler Bass, following missed field goal
- Mexican tourist haven and silversmithing town of Taxco shuttered by gang killings and threats
- Former Spanish Soccer Federation President to Face Trial for Kissing Jenni Hermoso After World Cup Win
Recommendation
-
Roster limits in college small sports put athletes on chopping block while coaches look for answers
-
This plant and these animals could be added to the Endangered Species Act
-
Russia fires genetics institute head who claimed humans once lived for 900 years
-
Robitussin cough syrup sold nationwide recalled due to contamination
-
Karol G addresses backlash to '+57' lyric: 'I still have a lot to learn'
-
Former Spanish Soccer Federation President to Face Trial for Kissing Jenni Hermoso After World Cup Win
-
Pickleball has taken the nation by storm. Now, it's become a competitive high-school sport
-
Doc Rivers set to become head coach of Milwaukee Bucks: Here's his entire coaching resume