Current:Home > FinanceFormer NFL players are suing the league over denied disability benefits-LoTradeCoin
Former NFL players are suing the league over denied disability benefits
View Date:2024-12-23 20:22:38
A group of former National Football League players is suing the organization, alleging that it has a pattern of denying disability benefits for those with both physical injuries and mental impairments, despite evidence from medical and team records.
The plaintiffs include Jason Alford, Daniel Loper, Willis McGahee, Michael McKenzie, Jamize Olawale, Alex Parsons, Eric Smith, Charles Sims, Joey Thomas and Lance Zeno.
They are "seeking redress for the wrongful denial of benefits, the denial of statutorily mandated full and fair review of benefits denials, violations of plan terms or governing regulations, and breaches of fiduciary duty," according to the complaint, which was filed Thursday in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland.
Several of them had their applications for benefits denied on multiple occasions, marred by conflicting reports from doctors with denial rates often exceeding more than 90%, the lawsuit says.
The complaint suggests the doctors who analyzed the plaintiffs were highly paid by the league, and therefore purposefully minimized the former players' complaints in reports so the league was justified in denying their applications to avoid payouts. Conversely, doctors who made less were more likely to accurately detect disabilities, the lawsuit says.
For example, the complaint says a doctor who evaluated Smith was never paid more than $72,765 in a year from the board in 11 years. From April 2015 through March 2016, he was paid $34,268. The next year, after the doctor found 20 impairment points during his examination of Smith – and the player was approved for disability benefits – the doctor's pay fell to $16,711.
The plaintiffs point out that physicians are supposed to be neutral, but the league does not have a system in place to audit physicians' reports or collect data on how many claims are approved or denied, and does not penalize those who make inaccurate or incomplete reports.
The NFL was not immediately available for comment, but on Wednesday, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell was asked at a press conference how he justifies so many players being denied disability benefits.
"We have to obviously have a system to be able to identify who qualifies for those benefits and who doesn't qualify for those benefits, and that's done with union and management," he said. "And the facts are that's done independently with doctors who make a determination of whether ... an individual qualifies under that program."
"So you don't want people to benefit from it that don't qualify for it, because it takes away from people who do qualify for it. So you're always going to have people who may think they qualify for it – doctors disagree, the joint board disagrees. That's a way the system works, but I would tell you the benefits in the NFL are off the charts."
Goodell is listed as a defendant in the suit, and is also on the board of the NFL Player Disability and Neurocognitive Benefit Plan. He said about $2.5 billion of the league's $10 billion player compensation package this year is for benefits.
Yearly disability compensation can range from $65,000 a year to $265,000 a year, depending on if the injury was sustained while performing activities for the league or not, and how long ago the injury happened.
A doctor for McGahee, who played 11 years as a running back, incorrectly stated McGahee was unimpaired, despite several tests showing impaired cognitive function, and used McGahee's demographic information, including his race, to estimate his IQ prior to the injury, the lawsuit says.
Education level and prior training is not allowed to be evaluated when determining players' benefits.
According to the lawsuit, Sims was approved for Inactive A benefits, which do not require an injury be sustained during a player's time in the league, even though he qualified for Total and Permanent benefits, which are given to those who have "become totally disabled to the extent that he is substantially prevented from or substantially unable to engage in any occupation or employment and such condition is permanent."
In Sims' decision letter, the seven-person board wrote that one member did not believe Sims sustained his injuries – including "'post-concussive syndrome' and multiple orthopedic 'NFL related impairments'" – during his four years in the league as a running back, despite the doctor's report saying so. Therefore, the board could not agree on a classification for Sims' benefits, the lawsuit says.
In an appeal, Sims submitted additional team and medical records, but was once again denied, as the board determined there still was no evidence proving Sims was injured as a player, according to the complaint.
The plaintiffs are seeking to make their complaint a class action lawsuit, have the current members of the board removed and be given monetary relief.
veryGood! (9)
Related
- Bill on school bathroom use by transgender students clears Ohio Legislature, heads to governor
- Pennsylvania police confirm 2 more sightings of Danelo Cavalcante as hunt for convicted killer continues
- Escaped murderer slips out of search area, changes appearance and tries to contact former co-workers
- NASCAR Kansas playoff race 2023: Start time, TV, streaming, lineup for Hollywood Casino 400
- Love Is Blind’s Chelsea Blackwell Reacts to Megan Fox’s Baby News
- UK leader Sunak chides China after report a UK Parliament staffer is a suspected Beijing spy
- 11 hurt when walkway collapses during Maine open lighthouse event
- Lauren Groff has a go bag and says so should you
- Trump breaks GOP losing streak in nation’s largest majority-Arab city with a pivotal final week
- Foreign student arrested in Norway on suspicion of espionage including electronic eavesdropping
Ranking
- In an AP interview, the next Los Angeles DA says he’ll go after low-level nonviolent crimes
- Judge denies Mark Meadows' request to move Georgia election case to federal court
- Ukraine: Americans back most U.S. steps for Ukraine as Republicans grow more split, CBS News poll finds
- For Deion Sanders and Shedeur Sanders, Colorado's defeat of Nebraska was 'personal'
- Elton John Details Strict Diet in His 70s
- Luis Rubiales, Spain's soccer federation boss, faces sexual assault lawsuit for Jenni Hermoso kiss
- Foreign student arrested in Norway on suspicion of espionage including electronic eavesdropping
- Pee-wee Herman Actor Paul Reubens' Cause of Death Revealed
Recommendation
-
NYC bans unusual practice of forcing tenants to pay real estate brokers hired by landlords
-
Walter Isaacson on Elon Musk: It's almost like Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
-
Jennifer Garner's Trainer Wants You to Do This in the Gym
-
Here's how to ask for a letter of recommendation (and actually get a good one.)
-
Halle Berry Rocks Sheer Dress She Wore to 2002 Oscars 22 Years Later
-
Morocco earthquake live updates: Aftershock rocks rescuers as death toll surpasses 2,000
-
‘The Nun II’ conjures $32.6 million to top box office
-
Air China jet evacuated after engine fire sends smoke into cabin in Singapore, and 9 people injured