Current:Home > MyA judge temporarily blocks Iowa law that allows authorities to charge people facing deportation-LoTradeCoin
A judge temporarily blocks Iowa law that allows authorities to charge people facing deportation
View Date:2024-12-23 22:33:11
DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — A federal judge on Monday temporarily blocked an Iowa law that would have allowed law enforcement in the state to file criminal charges against people with outstanding deportation orders or who previously had been denied entry to the U.S.
U.S. District Court Judge Stephen Locher issued a preliminary injunction because he said the U.S. Department of Justice and civil rights groups who filed suit against the state were likely to succeed in their argument that federal immigration law preempted the law approved this spring by Iowa lawmakers. He stopped enforcement of the law “pending further proceedings.”
“As a matter of politics, the new legislation might be defensible,” Locher wrote in his decision. “As a matter of constitutional law, it is not.”
The Iowa law, which was set to take effect July 1, would let law enforcement file charges to be brought against people who have outstanding deportation orders or who previously have been removed from or denied admission to the U.S. Once in custody, migrants could either agree to a judge’s order to leave the U.S. or be prosecuted, potentially facing time in prison before deportation.
In approving the law, Iowa’s Republican-majority Legislature and Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds said they took the action because the administration of Democratic President Joe Biden wasn’t effective in controlling immigration along the nation’s southern border.
In arguments last week before Locher, the state said the Iowa law would only enable state law enforcement and courts to apply federal law, not create new law. Federal authorities determine who violates U.S. immigration law, Patrick Valencia, Iowa’s deputy solicitor general, had argued, but once that is determined, the person also was in violation of state law.
“We have a law that adopts the federal standard,” Valencia said.
However, the federal government and civil rights groups said the Iowa law violated the federal government’s sole authority over immigration matters and would create a host of problems and confusion.
Christopher Eiswerth, a DOJ attorney, and Emma Winger, representing the American Immigration Council, said the new Iowa law didn’t make an exception for people who had once been deported but now were in the country legally, including those seeking asylum.
The law is similar but less expansive than a Texas law, which was in effect for only a few confusing hours in March before it was put on hold by a federal appeals court’s three-judge panel.
The Justice Department has also announced it would seek to stop a similar law in Oklahoma.
Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird said in statement that she would appeal the judge’s decision.
“I am disappointed in today’s court decision that blocks Iowa from stopping illegal reentry and keeping our communities safe,” Bird said. “Since Biden refuses to secure our borders, he has left states with no choice but to do the job for him.”
Reynolds issued a statement that also expressed frustration at the judge’s ruling and criticized Biden.
“I signed this bill into law to protect Iowans and our communities from the results of this border crisis: rising crime, overdose deaths, and human trafficking,” Reynolds said.
Rita Bettis Austen, legal director of the ACLU of Iowa, one of the organizations that filed the lawsuit, praised the judge’s decision, saying the law dumped a federal responsibility onto local law enforcement that wasn’t prepared to take on the role.
Bettis Austen called the law “among the worst anti-immigrant legislation in Iowa’s history,” adding that it “exposed even lawful immigrants, and even children, to serious harms — arrest, detention, deportation, family separation, and incarceration, by the state.”
veryGood! (4)
Related
- One person is dead after a shooting at Tuskegee University
- Opinion: Trading for Davante Adams is a must for plunging Jets to save season
- Inside Daisy Kelliher and Gary King's Tense BDSY Reunion—And Where They Stand Today
- Madonna’s Brother Christopher Ciccone Dead at 63
- The Best Corduroy Pants Deals from J.Crew Outlet, Old Navy, Levi’s & More, Starting at $26
- Aaron Rodgers injury update: Jets QB suffers low-ankle sprain vs. Vikings
- Minnesota ranger dies during water rescue at Voyageurs National Park
- RHOSLC Star Whitney Rose's 14-Year-Old Daughter Bobbie Taken to the ICU
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, 4G
- Eviction prevention in Los Angeles helps thousands, including landlords
Ranking
- Bowl projections: SEC teams joins College Football Playoff field
- Rosie O'Donnell says she's 'like a big sister' to Menendez brothers Lyle and Erik
- Dodgers' Freddie Freeman leaves NLDS Game 2 against Padres with ankle discomfort
- Michigan gun owner gets more than 3 years in prison for accidental death of grandson
- US Diplomats Notch a Win on Climate Super Pollutants With Help From the Private Sector
- Donald Glover cancels Childish Gambino tour dates after recent surgery
- Minnesota ranger dies during water rescue at Voyageurs National Park
- Guster, Avett Brothers and Florence Welch are helping bring alt-rock to the musical theater stage
Recommendation
-
Auburn surges, while Kansas remains No. 1 in the USA TODAY Sports men's basketball poll
-
Meghan Markle Turns Heads in Red Gown During Surprise Appearance at Children’s Hospital Gala
-
NFL games today: Start time, TV info for Sunday's Week 5 matchups
-
Dave Hobson, Ohio congressman who backed D-Day museum, has died at 87
-
Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Something Corporate
-
Inside Daisy Kelliher and Gary King's Tense BDSY Reunion—And Where They Stand Today
-
US disaster relief chief blasts false claims about Helene response as a ‘truly dangerous narrative’
-
Opinion: Dak Prescott comes up clutch, rescues Cowboys with late heroics vs. Steelers