Current:Home > MySupreme Court sides with Jack Daniels in trademark fight over poop-themed dog toy-LoTradeCoin
Supreme Court sides with Jack Daniels in trademark fight over poop-themed dog toy
View Date:2024-12-23 16:32:06
Washington — The Supreme Court on Thursday sided with whiskey maker Jack Daniels in a dispute with a pet company selling a poop-themed dog chew toy that mimics the brand's iconic square bottle, tossing out a lower court ruling against the drink company.
In an unanimous, narrow decision authored by Justice Elena Kagan, the high court wiped away the lower court ruling from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit and sent the case, known as Jack Daniel's Properties v. VIP Products LLC, back to the lower courts for further consideration.
"We hold only that it is not appropriate when the accused infringer has used a trademark to designate the source of its own goods — in other words, has used a trademark as a trademark," Kagan wrote. "That kind of use falls within the heartland of trademark law, and does not receive special First Amendment protection."
The Supreme Court said lower courts must now consider whether the products from VIP Products invoking Jack Daniels and its iconic whiskey bottle — which VIP Products says parody the beverage brand — are likely to cause confusion for consumers.
"A parody must 'conjure up' 'enough of [an] original to make the object of its critical wit recognizable,'" Kagan wrote. "Yet to succeed, the parody must also create contrasts, so that its message of ridicule or pointed humor comes clear. And once that is done (if that is done), a parody is not often likely to create confusion. Self-deprecation is one thing; self-mockery far less ordinary."
The justices were chewing on a dispute that stemmed from a line of dog toys made by the Arizona-based company VIP Products called "Bad Spaniels." The toy mimics a Jack Daniel's whiskey bottle, but with a poop-themed twist. While the whiskey bottle says "Old No. 7," the dog toy says "Old No. 2," and instead of "Tennessee Sour Mash Whiskey," the chew toy reads "on your Tennessee carpet." References to alcohol content on a Jack Daniel's bottle, "40% ALC. BY VOL. (80 PROOF)," became "43% POO BY VOL." and "100% SMELLY."
While the head of VIP Products said the motivation behind the toy was to create a parody product that amused the public, Jack Daniel's did not like the joke, and the company sought to stop VIP from selling the Bad Spaniel's toy under federal trademark law.
That law, the Lanham Act, prohibits using a trademark in a way that is likely to cause confusion about its origin, and Jack Daniels claimed the dog toy likely confused consumers and therefore infringed its marks and trade dress.
Jack Daniel's prevailed before a federal district court, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit reversed, finding in part that the liquor company's designs were used by VIP Products to convey a humorous message that was protected from trademark-infringement claims under the First Amendment.
veryGood! (33)
Related
- My Little Pony finally hits the Toy Hall of Fame, alongside Phase 10 and Transformers
- Conjoined Twins Abby and Brittany Hensel Revisit Wedding Day With a Nod to Taylor Swift
- Lenny Kravitz says he's open to finding love: I've never felt how I feel now
- List of winners at the 77th Cannes Film Festival
- Special counsel Smith asks court to pause appeal seeking to revive Trump’s classified documents case
- Luka Doncic's 3-pointer over Rudy Gobert gives Mavs dramatic win, 2-0 lead over Timberwolves
- Dolphin stuck in NJ creek dies after ‘last resort’ rescue attempt, officials say
- Deion's son Shilo Sanders facing legal mess after filing for bankruptcy
- AI could help scale humanitarian responses. But it could also have big downsides
- What will win the Palme d’Or? Cannes closes Saturday with awards and a tribute to George Lucas
Ranking
- New York races to revive Manhattan tolls intended to fight traffic before Trump can block them
- Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton to miss Game 3 vs. Celtics with hamstring injury
- Luka Doncic's 3-pointer over Rudy Gobert gives Mavs dramatic win, 2-0 lead over Timberwolves
- Lenny Kravitz says he's open to finding love: I've never felt how I feel now
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Red Velvet, Please
- Gen Z is redefining what workers should expect from their employers. It's a good thing.
- 2 climbers die on Mount Everest, 3 still missing on world's highest mountain: It is a sad day
- National Spelling Bee reflects the economic success and cultural impact of immigrants from India
Recommendation
-
Forget the bathroom. When renovating a home, a good roof is a no-brainer, experts say.
-
3 injured, 1 arrested at Skyline High School's graduation in Oakland, California: Police
-
Conjoined Twins Abby and Brittany Hensel Revisit Wedding Day With a Nod to Taylor Swift
-
NCAA lacrosse semifinals: Notre Dame rolls Denver, Maryland tops Virginia for title game spot
-
Wendi McLendon-Covey talks NBC sitcom 'St. Denis Medical' and hospital humor
-
MLB's five biggest surprises: Are these teams contenders or pretenders in 2024?
-
Lawsuit filed in the death of dancer with a peanut allergy who died after eating mislabeled cookie
-
What is the first round order for the 2024 NHL draft? Who are the top prospects?