Current:Home > InvestMan who served longest wrongful conviction in U.S. history files lawsuit against police-LoTradeCoin
Man who served longest wrongful conviction in U.S. history files lawsuit against police
View Date:2024-12-23 20:41:54
The man who served the longest wrongful conviction in U.S. history is now suing the law enforcement officials whose investigation of a murder nearly 50 years ago led to him spending most of his life in prison.
Attorneys for Glynn Simmons filed a lawsuit in federal court Friday against two former Oklahoma police detectives and their respective departments alleging the two hid evidence that would have proven Simmons' innocence in a 1974 fatal shooting.
A judge ordered Simmons' release from prison last year after he served 48 years for his wrongful conviction in the death of Carolyn Sue Rogers, the clerk of a liquor store Simmons was accused of robbing in Edmond, a city around 15 miles north of Oklahoma City.
Simmons' legal team alleges that retired Oklahoma City detective Claude Shobert and late Edmond detective Sgt. Anthony Garrett hid evidence that would have proven Simmons' innocence during an Edmond liquor store robbery. Convicted of murder in 1975, Simmons has always maintained he did not commit the crime and insisted he was in Louisiana at the time of the shooting, but he spent 48 years in prison until an Oklahoma County judge ordered him released in 2023 and then determined Simmons to be "actually innocent" later that year.
Simmons' lawyers argue that his constitutional rights were violated because investigators withheld a police report showing that eyewitness Belinda Brown — who was also shot in the head but survived — did not actually identify Simmons during a lineup. The attorneys point to Brown's participation in several other lineups and her identification of at least five different individuals as further proof of Simmons' innocence. They also allege that investigators falsified reports to cover up inconsistencies from Brown, who herself told Garrett in early January 1975 that her memories "would get all jumbled up."
"Garrett and Shobert suppressed the fact that they fabricated evidence and manipulated Brown’s identification; they never disclosed this information to (Simmons), his counsel, or the prosecutors," the attorneys wrote in the lawsuit. "(Simmons') arrest was based solely on the evidence suppressed and fabricated by Defendants Garrett and Shobert. There was never any probable cause to suspect (him) of the liquor store robbery and murder."
More:With Glynn Simmons free, is Carolyn Sue Rogers' 1974 murder now a cold case?
The lawsuit was filed Friday in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma. Simmons is being represented by attorneys Jon Loevy, Jordan Poole and Elizabeth Wang of Loevy & Loevy, a national civil rights law firm headquartered in Chicago. Simmons also is being represented by Joe Norwood, his Tulsa-based attorney for several years, and John Coyle, of the Oklahoma City-based Coyle Law Firm.
Norwood and Coyle successfully advocated for Simmons' release and formal exoneration in 2023. The attorneys said Simmons needed to be found "actually innocent" in Oklahoma County court in order to begin officially pursuing financial compensation for the decades he spent wrongfully incarcerated.
"He's pursuing whatever a jury will award him, which we are certain, if this case goes to a jury trial, will be much more than $10 million," Wang told The Oklahoman, part of the USA TODAY network, Friday. "Oklahoma City has an ordinance that provided that they're required to indemnify up to $10 million. That's what they're required to do."
Simmons' attorneys argue that the cities of Edmond and Oklahoma City are liable for constitutional violations "by virtue of (their) official policies."
"The Cities failed to promulgate any or adequate rules, regulations, policies or procedures on: the handling, preservation, and disclosure of exculpatory evidence; the writing of police reports and notes of witness statements; the conduct of lineups and identification procedures; and meaningful discipline of officers accused of such unlawful conduct," the lawyers wrote.
More:How much should Oklahomans wrongfully incarcerated be paid? Lawmaker working to raise the amount
When contacted Saturday by The Oklahoman, Shobert, now 79, said he did not know about the lawsuit, but confirmed he worked for the Oklahoma City Police Department from 1968 to 1988. He also said he remembers nothing about the liquor store murder, the related lineups or the Glynn Simmons case.
“If it’s written on paper, then I have to stand by that. I’m not going to change nothing, because I don’t remember nothing,” Shobert said. “At the time, 49 years ago, if I wrote it down, then it’s still the same and nothing’s changing.”
Shobert also said he regularly was tasked with investigating robberies and typically was not assigned homicide work unless homicide investigators “were all tied up,” and even then, he said, it was typically in an assistant role, not as a lead.
“After 49 years, it had to be something really special for me to remember, and since I don’t remember none of it, there’s nothing I can do about it,” Shobert told The Oklahoman.
Spokespeople for Edmond and Oklahoma City said Friday they could not comment on ongoing litigation.
Another man, Don Roberts, also was convicted in 1975 of Rogers' murder, although he said he was in Texas at the time of the crime. He and Simmons both were initially sentenced to death row, before a 1977 U.S. Supreme Court ruling caused their sentences to be modified to life in prison. Roberts was eventually paroled in 2008 but, according to law enforcement, his conviction still stands.
veryGood! (16)
Related
- Wheel of Fortune Contestant Goes Viral Over His Hilariously Wrong Answer
- After 25 Years of Futility, Democrats Finally Jettison Carbon Pricing in Favor of Incentives to Counter Climate Change
- Earth Has a 50-50 Chance of Hitting a Grim Global Warming Milestone in the Next Five Years
- New Reports Show Forests Need Far More Funding to Help the Climate, and Even Then, They Can’t Do It All
- Kennesaw State football coach Brian Bohannon steps down after 10 seasons amid first year in FBS
- Restock Alert: Get Hailey Bieber’s Rhode Glazing Milk Before It Sells Out, Again
- Honoring Bruce Lee
- Honoring Bruce Lee
- Gun groups sue to overturn Maine’s new three-day waiting period to buy firearms
- About 1 in 10 young adults are vaping regularly, CDC report finds
Ranking
- USMNT Concacaf Nations League quarterfinal Leg 1 vs. Jamaica: Live stream and TV, rosters
- ConocoPhillips’ Plan for Extracting Half-a-Billion Barrels of Crude in Alaska’s Fragile Arctic Presents a Defining Moment for Joe Biden
- How one small change in Japan could sway U.S. markets
- How America's largest newspaper company is leaving behind news deserts
- What to know about Mississippi Valley State football player Ryan Quinney, who died Friday
- Businesses face more and more pressure from investors to act on climate change
- Inside Clean Energy: Drought is Causing U.S. Hydropower to Have a Rough Year. Is This a Sign of a Long-Term Shift?
- Inside Clean Energy: Here’s Why Some Utilities Support, and Others Are Wary of, the Federal Clean Energy Proposal
Recommendation
-
Guns smuggled from the US are blamed for a surge in killings on more Caribbean islands
-
An indicator that often points to recession could be giving a false signal this time
-
The inverted yield curve is screaming RECESSION
-
Senate Votes to Ratify the Kigali Amendment, Joining 137 Nations in an Effort to Curb Global Warming
-
Kennesaw State football coach Brian Bohannon steps down after 10 seasons amid first year in FBS
-
Inside Clean Energy: Here’s Why Some Utilities Support, and Others Are Wary of, the Federal Clean Energy Proposal
-
Biden Administration Stops Short of Electric Vehicle Mandates for Trucks
-
Activists Take Aim at an Expressway Project in Karachi, Saying it Will Only Heighten Climate Threats
Like
- Man jailed after Tuskegee University shooting says he fired his gun, but denies shooting at anyone
- Christy Carlson Romano Reacts to Chrissy Teigen and John Legend’s Even Stevens-Approved Baby Name
- Warming Trends: The Climate Atlas of Canada Maps ‘the Harshities of Life,’ Plus Christians Embracing Climate Change and a New Podcast Called ‘Hot Farm’