Current:Home > StocksParents of a terminally ill baby lose UK legal battle to bring her home-LoTradeCoin
Parents of a terminally ill baby lose UK legal battle to bring her home
View Date:2024-12-23 20:47:42
LONDON (AP) — A judge at Britain’s High Court ruled Wednesday that life support for a terminally ill 8-month-old baby should be withdrawn in a hospice or hospital, despite efforts by the infant’s parents and the Italian government to transport her to Italy for further treatment.
The parents of baby Indi Gregory, who has a rare metabolic disorder known as mitochondrial disease, have fought legal battles in a bid to continue life support for their child. But a judge has ruled that doctors can lawfully limit life-supporting invasive treatment, because continuing with the treatment would not be in the child’s best interests.
The legal tussle is the latest in a series of similar cases in Britain that saw doctors and parents spar over the treatment of terminally ill children and the respective rights and responsibilities of parents and medical professionals.
In a written ruling, Justice Robert Peel said he accepted the evidence of medical specialists at the Queen’s Medical Center in Nottingham arguing that treatment for Indi should be withdrawn in a hospice or hospital.
The baby’s parents had hoped to fly Indi to Italy — where the Vatican’s pediatric hospital, Bambino Gesu, has offered to care for her — or failing that bring the infant home for end-of-life care.
But Justice Peel ruled it was “too dangerous” to send the baby home “given the clinical complications.”
“There are a number of factors which render extubation and palliative care at the family home all but impossible, and certainly contrary to (Indi’s) best interests,” he said.
He had already ruled that a transfer to Italy would not be in the baby’s best interests, and Court of Appeal judges have backed that decision.
Britain’s National Health Service says there is no current cure for mitochondrial disease, which means a patient’s cells aren’t able to produce enough energy to operate properly. The fatal disease has caused progressive brain damage in baby Indi, leaving her totally dependent on life support, according to evidence presented to the High Court in London.
Justice Peel has said his decision was based on findings that Indi was critically ill, had no prospect of improvement and an “extremely limited quality of life,” combined with evidence that she experienced frequent pain as a result of her treatment.
His decision has not changed despite offers from the Italian government this week to airlift Indi to the Vatican hospital and pay for any treatment in Italy. The Italian government has also granted Indi citizenship to help facilitate her transport and treatment.
Italian Premier Giorgia Meloni said Monday she would “do what I can do to defend (Indi’s) life” and “defend the right of her mamma and papa to do all that they can for her.”
But Peel said a letter from the Vatican hospital provided little detail about the proposed treatment for Indi, and there was no evidence that experimental treatments would improve her quality of life. Instead, he said continuation of treatment would “perpetuate a high level of pain and suffering” for the baby.
Dean Gregory, Indi’s father, said it was “disgraceful” for doctors and British courts to ignore the offer from Italy’s government.
“As a father I have never asked or begged for anything in my life, but I am now begging the British government to please help prevent our daughter’s life from being taken away,” he said in a statement released through Christian Concern, a charity supporting the family.
In recent years Britain’s judges and doctors have repeatedly come under criticism from Christian groups and others, including politicians in Italy and Poland, for upholding decisions to end life support for terminally ill children when that conflicts with the parents’ wishes.
Under British law, the key test in such cases is whether a proposed treatment is in the best interests of the child.
veryGood! (7797)
Related
- Nicole Kidman Reveals the Surprising Reason for Starring in NSFW Movie Babygirl
- Calling All Cupids: Anthropologie’s Valentine’s Day Shop Is Full of Date Night Outfits & More Cute Finds
- 'Griselda' cast, release date, where to watch Sofía Vergara star as Griselda Blanco in new series
- Billy Idol talks upcoming pre-Super Bowl show, recent Hoover Dam performance, working on a new album
- Sean Diddy Combs' Lawyers File New Motion for Bail, Claiming Evidence Depicts a Consensual Relationship
- Russia accuses Ukraine of shooting down plane carrying Ukrainian prisoners of war in Belgorod region
- Maine’s top court dismisses appeal of judge’s decision on Trump ballot status
- What is Jim Harbaugh's NFL record? Everything you need to know about Chargers new coach
- Katharine Hayhoe’s Post-Election Advice: Fight Fear, Embrace Hope and Work Together
- Pickleball has taken the nation by storm. Now, it's become a competitive high-school sport
Ranking
- Mega Millions winning numbers for November 8 drawing: Jackpot rises to $361 million
- 'Feud: Capote vs. The Swans': Premiere date, cast, trailer, what to know about new season
- South Carolina GOP governor blasts labor unions while touting economic growth in annual address
- NBC Sports, Cosm partner to bring college football to 'shared reality' viewing experience
- Amazon Black Friday 2024 sales event will start Nov. 21: See some of the deals
- Brazil’s former intelligence boss investigated in probe of alleged political spying, official says
- Who Pays for Cleanup When a Solar Project Reaches the End of Its Life?
- Trump could testify as trial set to resume in his legal fight with E. Jean Carroll
Recommendation
-
Wisconsin agency issues first round of permits for Enbridge Line 5 reroute around reservation
-
Iran disqualifies former moderate president from running for reelection to influential assembly
-
Gene therapy shows promise for an inherited form of deafness
-
What is Jim Harbaugh's NFL record? Everything you need to know about Chargers new coach
-
Kirk Herbstreit berates LSU fans throwing trash vs Alabama: 'Enough is enough, clowns'
-
Residents of northern Australia batten down homes, businesses ahead of Tropical Cyclone Kirrily
-
A record number of Americans are choosing to work part-time. Here's why.
-
Supreme Court allows Alabama to carry out first-ever execution by nitrogen gas of death row inmate Kenneth Smith