Current:Home > MyArizona proposal to let local police make border-crossing arrests is set for lawmakers’ final vote-LoTradeCoin
Arizona proposal to let local police make border-crossing arrests is set for lawmakers’ final vote
View Date:2024-12-23 19:34:28
PHOENIX (AP) — Arizona would step directly into immigration enforcement by making it a state crime to cross the Arizona-Mexico border anywhere except a port of entry, under a proposal that’s up for a final vote by lawmakers on Tuesday. If approved, voters would decide in November if the measure becomes law.
The measure, scheduled for a vote in the Arizona House, would let state and local police arrest people crossing the border without authorization. It also would empower state judges to order people convicted of the offense to go back to their home country.
The proposal is similar to a Texas law that has been put on hold by a federal appeals court while it’s being challenged. The Arizona Senate approved the proposal on a 16-13 party-line vote. If it clears the House, the proposal would bypass Democratic Gov. Katie Hobbs, who vetoed a similar proposal in early March, and instead get sent to the Nov. 5 ballot.
While federal law already prohibits the unauthorized entry of migrants into the U.S., proponents of the measure say it’s needed because the federal government hasn’t done enough to stop people from crossing illegally over Arizona’s vast, porous border with Mexico. They also said some people who enter Arizona without authorization commit identity theft and take advantage of public benefits.
Opponents say the proposal would inevitably lead to racial profiling by police and saddle the state with new costs from law enforcement agencies that don’t have experience with immigration law, as well as hurt Arizona’s reputation in the business world.
Supporters of the proposed ballot measure waved off concerns about racial profiling, saying local officers would still have to develop probable cause to arrest people who enter Arizona outside ports of entry.
The backers also say the measure focuses only on the state’s border region and — unlike Arizona’s landmark 2010 immigration law — doesn’t target people throughout the state. Opponents point out the proposal doesn’t contain any geographical limitations on where it can be enforced within the state.
The ballot proposal contains other provisions that aren’t included in the Texas measure and aren’t directly related to immigration. Those include making it a felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison for selling fentanyl that leads to a person’s death, and a requirement that government agencies that administer benefit programs use a federal database to verify that a noncitizen’s eligibility for benefits.
Warning about potential legal costs, opponents pointed to Arizona’s 2005 immigrant smuggling ban used by then-Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio to carry out 20 large-scale traffic patrols that targeted immigrants. That led to a 2013 racial profiling verdict and taxpayer-funded legal and compliance costs that now total $265 million and are expected to reach $314 million by July 2025.
Under the current proposal, a first-time conviction of the border-crossing provision would be a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in jail. State judges could order people to return to their countries of origin after completing a term of incarceration, although the courts would have the power to dismiss cases if those arrested agree to return home.
The measure would require the state corrections department to take into custody people who are charged or convicted under the measure if local or county law enforcement agencies don’t have enough space to house them.
The proposal includes exceptions for people who have been granted lawful presence status or asylum by the federal government.
The provision allowing for the arrests of border crossers in between ports would not take effect until the Texas law or similar laws from other states have been in effect for 60 days.
This isn’t the first time Republican lawmakers in Arizona have tried to criminalize migrants who aren’t authorized to be in the United States.
When passing its 2010 immigration bill, the Arizona Legislature considered expanding the state’s trespassing law to criminalize the presence of immigrants and impose criminal penalties. But the trespassing language was removed and replaced with a requirement that officers, while enforcing other laws, question people’s immigration status if they were believed to be in the country illegally.
The questioning requirement was ultimately upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court despite the racial profiling concerns of critics, but courts barred enforcement of other sections of the law.
veryGood! (9)
Related
- See Chris Evans' Wife Alba Baptista Show Her Sweet Support at Red One Premiere
- Jennifer Lopez shares photos from Georgia wedding to Ben Affleck on first anniversary
- Tropical Storm Hilary moves on from California, leaving a trail of damage and debris
- Las Vegas declares state of emergency ahead of Tropical Storm Hilary's impact
- Powerball winning numbers for November 11 drawing: Jackpot hits $103 million
- Feel Comfy and Look Professional in These Sweatpants That Look Like Work Pants
- Is Dodger Stadium flooded? No, it was just an illusion
- Jennifer Lopez shares photos from Georgia wedding to Ben Affleck on first anniversary
- MLS playoff teams set: Road to MLS Cup continues with conference semifinals
- 2 men jump overboard when yacht goes up in flames off Maine coast
Ranking
- Travis Kelce's and Patrick Mahomes' Kansas City Houses Burglarized
- Ex-wife charged with murder in ambush-style killing of Microsoft executive Jared Bridegan, may face death penalty
- U.S. expands Ukrainian immigration program to 167,000 new potential applicants
- Tropical Storm Hilary drenches Southern California, Spain wins World Cup: 5 Things podcast
- Full House's John Stamos Shares Message to Costar Dave Coulier Amid Cancer Battle
- The Bidens will travel to Maui to meet with wildfire survivors and first responders
- What are peptides? Understand why some people take them.
- Bachelor Nation's Krystal Nielson Marries Miles Bowles
Recommendation
-
California researchers discover mysterious, gelatinous new sea slug
-
Save 42% On That Vitamix Blender You’ve Always Wanted
-
Social Security COLA increase will ‘return to reality’ in 2024 after jump, predictions say
-
Charges dismissed in high-speed attempted murder case near Bismarck
-
Gossip Girl Actress Chanel Banks Reported Missing After Vanishing in California
-
Virginia judge largely sides with ex-patients in hospital’s effort to pare down lawsuit abuse claims
-
Biden heading to Maui amid criticism of White House response to devastating Lahaina wildfire
-
2 men jump overboard when yacht goes up in flames off Maine coast