Current:Home > NewsAlaska’s Soon-To-Be Climate Refugees Sue Energy Companies for Relocation-LoTradeCoin
Alaska’s Soon-To-Be Climate Refugees Sue Energy Companies for Relocation
View Date:2024-12-24 00:29:52
Kivalina, a small Inupiat village in northwestern Alaska, is being forced to relocate.
Its 400 residents will shortly become some of the world’s first climate refugees. And they’re taking a rather novel route for paying for the move: They’re suing a group of energy companies for creating a public nuisance and for conspiracy—that is, for funding research to “prove” there is no link between climate change and human activity.
The case, Native Village of Kivalina v. ExxonMobil Corp., et al., went to court a couple weeks ago in California and could be enormously important.
It is one of the first lawsuits tied to anthropogenic global warming that seeks to use conspiracy law to press for civil damages from trans-national corporations—in this case, up to $400 million, the upper-bound estimate for relocation costs.
Kivalina is endangered because thinning sea ice and surging seas threaten its territorial integrity. Waves that were once blocked by sea ice lap and slam into the community’s buildings regularly. The Army Corps of Engineers asserted in 2006 that the situation was “dire,” while the U.S. General Accounting Office gives numbers for relocating at up to $400 million.
If the conspiracy argument sounds familiar, a look at the Kivalinians’ lead attorney list offers a hint and a touch of irony: Lead co-counsel Steve Susman, a partner at Susman Godfrey LLP, represented tobacco conglomerate Philip Morris against the array of lawsuits filed against it by state attorneys general in the 1990s. He probably knows a good bit about the relevant portions of civil conspiracy statutes that residents of Kivalina are charging the defendants with violating.
The complaint reads,
Kivalina brings this action against defendants under federal common law and, in the alternative, state law, to seek damages for defendants’ contributions to global warming, a nuisance that is causing severe harm to Kivalina. Kivalina further asserts claims for civil conspiracy and concert of action for certain defendants’ participation in conspiratorial and other actions intended to further the defendants’ abilities to contribute to global warming. …
Additionally, some of the defendants, as described below, conspired to create a false scientific debate about global warming in order to deceive the public. Further, each defendant has failed promptly and adequately to mitigate the impact of these emissions, placing immediate profit above the need to protect against the harms from global warming.
The defendants include BP America, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, Peabody Energy, American Electric Power, Duke Energy and Southern Company, all of which were accused of conspiracy, plus several other companies accused of creating a public nuisance and also implicated in massive carbon emissions.
ExxonMobil spokesman Gantt Walton waved off the conspiracy claim, saying: “The recycling of this type of discredited conspiracy theory only diverts attention from the real challenge at hand — how to provide the energy to improve living standards while also reducing greenhouse gas emissions.”
It’s unclear if Walton was claiming that it was a “conspiracy theory” that energy corporations had funded fatuous climate research, since that’s a touch more like a documented fact.
That still doesn’t mean a quick or easy battle for the Kivalinians, though.
Legal analyst Dustin Till remarks that similar cases haven’t fared well. Judges have preferred to leave such supposedly contentious issues to legislators, being “political” and not legal issues.
But he adds that while the case may well fail to prevail, due to issues relating to causation, “jurisdictional challenges,” and whether or not there are justiciable claims,
“success on the merits could open a floodgate of similar litigation by other coastal jurisdictions that are grappling with the costs of adapting to rising sea levels and other environmental changes attributable to global warming.”
It’s not total non-sense that the companies that profited most from emitting carbon into the commons should have to pay for the consequences of their actions.
See also:
Melting Ice Could Lead to Massive Waves of Climate Refugees
Ocean Refugee Alert: The Torres Strait Islands are Drowning
World’s First Climate Refugees to Leave Island Home
veryGood! (485)
Related
- US Diplomats Notch a Win on Climate Super Pollutants With Help From the Private Sector
- Churchill Downs lifts suspension of trainer Bob Baffert following Medina Spirit’s failed drug test
- Tiger Woods misses cut, finishes disastrous British Open at 14-over
- Federal appeals court dismisses suit challenging Tennessee drag restrictions law
- Stop What You're Doing—Moo Deng Just Dropped Her First Single
- Authorities recapture fugitive who used dead child's identity after escaping prison in 1994
- Taylor Swift's Alleged Stalker, Accused of Threatening Travis Kelce, Arrested at Germany Eras Tour
- Gen Z: Many stuck in 'parent trap,' needing financial help from Mom and Dad, survey finds
- What are the best financial advising companies? Help USA TODAY rank the top U.S. firms
- Too old to work? Some Americans on the job late in life bristle at calls for Biden to step aside
Ranking
- Brianna LaPaglia Addresses Zach Bryan's Deafening Silence After Emotional Abuse Allegations
- Rapper Sean Kingston and his mother indicted on federal charges in $1M fraud scheme
- Check your VPN, abortion seekers. New 'Vagina Privacy Network' aims to keep data safe
- Tell Me Lies Season 2 Finally Has a Premiere Date
- ‘I got my life back.’ Veterans with PTSD making progress thanks to service dog program
- Hot, inland California cities face the steepest water cuts with new conservation mandate
- Prince William and Kate Middleton Are Hiring a New Staff Member—and Yes, You Can Actually Apply
- Member of eBay security team sentenced in harassment scheme involving bloody Halloween pig mask
Recommendation
-
Waymo’s robotaxis now open to anyone who wants a driverless ride in Los Angeles
-
Indianapolis anti-violence activist is fatally shot in vehicle
-
Canada wants 12 new submarines to bolster Arctic defense as NATO watches Russia and China move in
-
Chiefs set deadline of 6 months to decide whether to renovate Arrowhead or build new — and where
-
Northern Taurid meteor shower hits peak activity this week: When and where to watch
-
Carol Burnett honors friend Bob Newhart with emotional tribute: 'As kind and nice as he was funny'
-
FACT FOCUS: A look at claims made at the Republican National Convention as Trump accepts nomination
-
As the Rio Grande runs dry, South Texas cities look to alternatives for water