Current:Home > BackMichigan’s top court gives big victory to people trying to recoup cash from foreclosures-LoTradeCoin
Michigan’s top court gives big victory to people trying to recoup cash from foreclosures
View Date:2024-12-24 00:25:39
DETROIT (AP) — The Michigan Supreme Court said Monday that its 2020 decision stopping local governments from keeping cash windfalls from the sale of foreclosed homes can be applied retroactively, meaning that hundreds of millions of dollars could potentially be returned to people who lost properties over unpaid taxes.
Local governments were “essentially stealing from people,” said Christina Martin, an attorney who argued the case for former property owners. “It doesn’t matter if it’s going to be expensive to pay them back. They have to pay them back.”
For years, counties kept profits from the sale of foreclosed homes or land — even if the leftover cash far exceeded the amount of unpaid property taxes.
For example, Uri Rafaeli owed $8.41 in taxes on a rental property in Southfield. The bill grew to $285 with penalties and interest. Oakland County sold the house for $24,500 but kept the balance, which was legal at the time.
The Supreme Court in 2020 said the practice violated the Michigan Constitution. And now the court said the ruling can be applied retroactively to foreclosures that happened before the opinion was released four years ago.
“It’s a no-brainer,” Martin said.
Writing for the court, Justice Brian Zahra said the case “involves governmental violation of the constitutional rights of numerous individuals.”
He said “we are not without sympathy” toward communities that kept the surplus cash because state law had allowed it.
“Nonetheless, while the problem originated with the Legislature,” Zahra wrote, “at the foundation of our government is the precept that no state officer or local government can justify a constitutional violation on the basis of a statutory directive.”
Phil Ellison, another attorney for former property owners, said tens of thousands of people now might qualify for payment.
The Michigan Municipal League, which represents local governments, argued against making the 2020 decision retroactive, saying communities shouldn’t be penalized for following what was allowed under law. Complying with this ruling could cost hundreds of millions of dollars, they warned.
“The result is potential fiscal chaos across the state, as local governments will be forced to either cut services or raise taxes and fees to make up the holes in their budgets,” the group said in a court filing.
___
Follow Ed White on X at https://twitter.com/edwritez
veryGood! (7478)
Related
- Oprah Winfrey denies being paid $1M for Kamala Harris rally: 'I was not paid a dime'
- Los Angeles authorities searching for children taken by parents during supervised visit
- 'Beloved' father who was clearing storm drains identified as victim of Alaska landslide
- Brandon Jenner's Wife Cayley Jenner Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3
- Katherine Schwarzenegger Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3 With Chris Pratt
- Paralympic Games opening ceremony starts the final chapter on a long summer of sport in Paris
- Hard Knocks recap: Velus Jones Jr., Ian Wheeler, Austin Reed get one last chance to impress Bears
- Bristol Palin Details “Gut-Wrenching” Way Her 15-Year-Old Son Tripp Told Her He Wanted to Live With Dad
- Georgia House Democrats shift toward new leaders after limited election gains
- Northeastern University student sues sorority and landlord over fall from window
Ranking
- How Jersey Shore's Sammi Sweetheart Giancola's Fiancé Justin May Supports Her on IVF Journey
- Travis Kelce invests in racehorse aptly named Swift Delivery
- San Diego police identify the officer killed in a collision with a speeding vehicle
- Museum opens honoring memory of Juan Gabriel, icon of Latin music
- Kraft Heinz stops serving school-designed Lunchables because of low demand
- New US rules try to make it harder for criminals to launder money by paying cash for homes
- 'So much shock': LA doctor to the stars fatally shot outside his office, killer at large
- In Final Rock Springs Resource Management Plan, BLM Sticks With Conservation Priorities, Renewable Energy Development
Recommendation
-
2024 'virtually certain' to be warmest year on record, scientists say
-
2 Arizona women found dead in overturned vehicle on Mexico highway, police say
-
Walmart's prices lowered on thousands of items except in this 'stubborn' food aisle
-
New Jersey man drowns while rescuing 2 of his children in Delaware River
-
Kirk Herbstreit berates LSU fans throwing trash vs Alabama: 'Enough is enough, clowns'
-
The Daily Money: Pricing the American Dream
-
Following protests, DeSantis says plan to develop state parks is ‘going back to the drawing board’
-
Brandon Jenner's Wife Cayley Jenner Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3