Current:Home > NewsNew Hampshire is sued over removal of marker dedicated to Communist Party leader-LoTradeCoin
New Hampshire is sued over removal of marker dedicated to Communist Party leader
View Date:2024-12-23 21:08:09
CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — Supporters of a former historical marker dedicated to a feminist and labor activist from New Hampshire who also led the U.S. Communist Party sued the state Monday, saying officials violated a law around administrative procedures and should put it back up.
The green and white sign describing the life of Elizabeth Gurley Flynn was installed May 1 in Concord close to where she was born Aug. 7, 1890. It was one of more than 275 across the state that describe people and places, from Revolutionary War soldiers to contemporary sports figures. But it was taken down two weeks after it went up.
Known as “The Rebel Girl” for her fiery speeches, Flynn was a founder of the American Civil Liberties Union and advocated for women’s voting rights and access to birth control. The marker said she joined the Communist Party in 1936 and was sent to prison in 1951. She was one of many party members prosecuted “under the notorious Smith Act,” the marker said, which forbade attempts to advocate, abet or teach the violent destruction of the U.S. government.
Flynn later chaired the Communist Party of the United States. She died at 74 in Moscow during a visit in 1964.
The marker had drawn criticism from two Republican members of the Executive Council, a five-member body that approves state contracts, judicial nominees and other positions, who argued it was inappropriate, given Flynn’s Communist involvement. Republican Gov. Chris Sununu agreed and called for a review of the historical marker process. It was removed in consultation with Sununu, according to Sarah Crawford Stewart, commissioner of the Department of Natural and Cultural Resources.
But “the marker was illegally removed based on ideological considerations that fly in the face of the historical marker program’s purpose,” said plaintiff Mary Lee Sargent, an American history teacher who, along with activist Arnold Alpert, filed the lawsuit against the state in superior court.
The lawsuit says that state officials violated the state’s Administrative Procedures Act, its historic markers program and the plaintiffs’ rights to due process by interfering with Sargent’s and Alpert’s rights “to duly petition for the approval and erection of a historical marker” near Gurley Flynn’s birthplace.
The complaint specifically names Secretary of State David Scanlan as representative of New Hampshire, along with Stewart and Transportation Commissioner William Cass. Messages seeking comment on the lawsuit were sent to all three, as well as to the New Hampshire attorney general’s office, which represents the state and its departments in litigation.
Under the current process, any person, municipality or agency can suggest a marker as long as they get 20 signatures from New Hampshire residents. Supporters must draft the marker’s text and provide footnotes and copies of supporting documentation, according to the state Division of Historical Resources. The division and a historical resources advisory group evaluate the criteria.
The lawsuit said that policies and guidelines used by the department to run the program are invalid because their adoption wasn’t consistent with requirements of the Administrative Procedures Act. The lawsuit said Stewart didn’t even follow the guidelines, which require the department to consult with an advisory historical resources council before markers are “retired.”
veryGood! (9641)
Related
- Nicky Hilton Shares Her Christmas Plans With Paris, the Secret To Perfect Skin & More Holiday Gift Picks
- DOJ slams New Jersey over COVID deaths at veterans homes, residents still at high risk
- Julie and Todd Chrisley to Be Released From Prison Earlier Than Expected
- As Federal Money Flows to Carbon Capture and Storage, Texas Bets on an Undersea Bonanza
- Arbitrator upholds 5-year bans of Bad Bunny baseball agency leaders, cuts agent penalty to 3 years
- Brussels Midi Station, once a stately gateway to Belgium, has turned into festering sore of nation
- Police have cell phone video of Julio Urías' altercation from domestic violence arrest
- 'The Long Island Serial Killer': How cell phone evidence led to a suspect in 3 cases
- Whoopi Goldberg calling herself 'a working person' garners criticism from 'The View' fans
- Brazil’s Lula seeks to project unity and bring the army in line during Independence Day events
Ranking
- Businesses at struggling corner where George Floyd was killed sue Minneapolis
- Sri Lanka’s ruling coalition defeats a no-confidence motion against the health minister
- Florida Supreme Court begins hearing abortion-ban case, could limit access in Southeast
- King Charles honors mother Queen Elizabeth II's legacy on 1st anniversary of her death
- How many dog breeds are there? A guide to groups recognized in the US
- Author traces 'surprising history' of words that label women and their lives
- Germany will keep Russian oil giant Rosneft subsidiaries under its control for another 6 months
- Italy’s government approves crackdown on juvenile crime after a spate of rapes and youth criminality
Recommendation
-
Democrat Janelle Bynum flips Oregon’s 5th District, will be state’s first Black member of Congress
-
Say Yes to These 20 Secrets About My Big Fat Greek Wedding
-
Migrant girl, 3, on bus from Texas died of pneumonia, intestinal disease, autopsy finds
-
Maria Sharapova’s Guide to the US Open: Tips To Beat the Heat and Ace the Day
-
Joel Embiid injury, suspension update: When is 76ers star's NBA season debut?
-
Man gets 110 years for killing ex-girlfriend, her grandmother outside Indiana auto seating plant
-
UN report says the world is way off track to curb global warming, but offers ways to fix that
-
The operation could start soon to rescue a sick American researcher 3,000 feet into a Turkish cave