Current:Home > FinanceSouth Carolina prosecutors want legislators who are lawyers off a judicial screening committee-LoTradeCoin
South Carolina prosecutors want legislators who are lawyers off a judicial screening committee
View Date:2024-12-23 16:12:49
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — Nine of South Carolina’s 16 elected prosecutors are asking to remove all legislators who are lawyers from a committee that decides which judicial candidates are put before the General Assembly for election.
All six of the lawmakers on the Judicial Merit Screening Commission are attorneys. Only one was mentioned by name in Monday’s letter: House Minority Leader Todd Rutherford. He responded with a news conference saying the prosecutors were making a power grab.
The prosecutors’ three-page letter cites several instances in which they said Rutherford influenced cases. It asks House and Senate leaders to replace attorneys on the commission with legislators who do not practice law.
“Quite frankly, it is shocking that Rep. Rutherford remains in such an important position, and that lawyer-legislators on JMSC have such influence over our judiciary,” the prosecutors wrote. “Trust us when we say that Rep. Rutherford’s tactics are not unique. Lawyer-legislators have undue influence over our judiciary.”
Five Republicans and four Democrats signed the letter.
Within hours, Rutherford, a Democrat, called a news conference to respond. He said the commission’s sole responsibility is to determine if lawyers are qualified to be judges. Members only limit which candidates are sent to the Legislature for consideration if more than three meet the requirements.
Rutherford challenged the prosecutors, who go by the title of solicitor in South Carolina, to make a formal ethics complaint against him specifying how he improperly influenced a judge.
“If they would like for the speaker of the House to take me off the Judicial Merit Selection Commission, they should at least show where I’ve done something wrong,” Rutherford said.
The dispute over how the state selects judges has grown contentious since the Legislature’s 2023 session ended in the spring. The complaints have been broad, ranging from concern about judges allowing violent, repeat offenders out on bail to complaints that not enough people of color have been elected.
The General Assembly elects judges after the Judicial Merit Selection Commission screens them. The commission conducts background checks, sends out questionnaires to determine temperament and judicial knowledge, and holds public hearings. If more than three candidates are qualified, the panel sends three names to the General Assembly.
Six of the 10 members of the commission are legislators. Some critics have suggested excluding lawmakers from the commission since they ultimately vote for judges.
Proposals have also been floated to have the governor nominate judicial candidates for the Legislature to vote on or to hold public elections for the judiciary branch.
Last week, Gov, Henry McMaster required magistrates, the lowest level of judges, to fill out a more detailed application for their jobs.
Republican House Speaker Murrell has created a special committee to review the entire judicial election system, and has ask for recommendations next year.
About three dozen legislative judicial elections are set for 2024, from chief justice of the state Supreme Court all the way to the Family Court system.
Rutherford said the complaining solicitors want to diminish the influence of defense attorneys and simply want more judges who are likely to side with prosecutors.
“This is about power, ” he said.
The letter was written by 16th Circuit Solicitor Kevin Brackett and signed by 8th Circuit Solicitor David Stumbo, 9th Circuit Solicitor Scarlett Wilson, 10th Circuit Solicitor David Wagner and 11th Circuit Solicitor Rick Hubbard, all Republicans. The Democratic signatories were 1st Circuit Solicitor David Pascoe, 3rd Circuit Solicitor Ernest “Chip” Finney, 4th Circuit Solicitor Will Rogers and 12th Circuit Solicitor Ed Clements.
___
Pollard is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.
veryGood! (12)
Related
- Black, red or dead: How Omaha became a hub for black squirrel scholarship
- Ex-U.S. official says Sen. Bob Menendez pressured him to quit interfering with my constituent
- A strong economy means more Americans are earning $400K. What's it mean for their taxes?
- 3 Beauty Pros Reveal How to Conceal Textured Skin Without Caking On Products
- Disruptions to Amtrak service continue after fire near tracks in New York City
- After a quarter century, Thailand’s LGBTQ Pride Parade is seen as a popular and political success
- Marco Troper, son of former YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki, died from an accidental overdose
- Michelle Obama's Mother Marian Shields Robinson Dead at 86
- Amazon Best Books of 2024 revealed: Top 10 span genres but all 'make you feel deeply'
- Square Books is a cultural hub in William Faulkner's home of Oxford, Mississippi
Ranking
- Tom Brady Admits He Screwed Up as a Dad to Kids With Bridget Moynahan and Gisele Bündchen
- Google admits its AI Overviews can generate some odd, inaccurate results
- Swimmer Katie Ledecky on athlete doping scandals: I think our faith in some of the systems is at an all-time low
- Drew Brees said he could have played another three years in NFL if not for arm trouble
- Traveling to Las Vegas? Here Are the Best Black Friday Hotel Deals
- Lawsuit ends over Confederate monument outside North Carolina courthouse
- Caitlin Clark and Indiana Fever edge Angel Reese and Chicago Sky for first home win, 71-70
- Feds charge retired 4-star Navy admiral in alleged bribery scheme
Recommendation
-
Florida State can't afford to fire Mike Norvell -- and can't afford to keep him
-
Feds charge retired 4-star Navy admiral in alleged bribery scheme
-
Pato O’Ward looks to bounce back from Indy 500 heartbreaker with a winning run at Detroit Grand Prix
-
U.S. to make millions of bird flu vaccine doses this summer, as cases grow
-
Jon Gruden joins Barstool Sports three years after email scandal with NFL
-
Mike Tyson’s fight with Jake Paul has been postponed after Tyson’s health episode
-
Google admits its AI Overviews can generate some odd, inaccurate results
-
Princess Kate to skip major U.K. military event in London over 2 months after announcing cancer treatment