Current:Home > InvestTrump’s lawyers rested their case after calling just 2 witnesses. Experts say that’s not unusual-LoTradeCoin
Trump’s lawyers rested their case after calling just 2 witnesses. Experts say that’s not unusual
View Date:2024-12-23 21:55:46
NEW YORK (AP) — Donald Trump’s legal team rested its case Tuesday in his hush money trial after calling just two witnesses and opting not to have the former president take the stand in his own defense.
But despite what Hollywood courtroom dramas might suggest, that isn’t all that unusual, according to criminal defense lawyers and former prosecutors.
The reason is simple: Prosecutors need to prove their case, while the defense only has to show there’s reasonable doubt their client committed a crime. And defense lawyers don’t necessarily need to call different witnesses to knock holes in a prosecutor’s case.
“The burden is on the prosecution, and it’s a high burden,” said Sarah Krissoff, a white-collar defense lawyer and former federal prosecutor in New York.
Trump has been charged with falsifying records at his company in order to disguise the true nature of payments made in 2017 to one of his lawyers, Michael Cohen. Prosecutors say the money was for Cohen’s work suppressing negative stories about his boss during the 2016 presidential campaign, including one about an alleged sexual encounter with a porn actor, Stormy Daniels. Trump, who denies Daniels’ account, has said the company properly classified them as legal expenses.
Most of the work of defense lawyers, Krissoff and other experts said, happens during cross-examination of the prosecution’s witnesses, when they can challenge their testimony and credibility.
“The defense narrative comes through during cross-examination, then they will tie it all together during the closing statement,” she explained.
It isn’t unusual for defense lawyers to call just a few witnesses of their own, or none at all.
A lot of the defense team’s work happens before the trial begins, and involves trying to make sure incriminating evidence isn’t admitted into the trial and is never seen or heard by the jury, Krissoff added.
“What you see in a courtroom is really only a sliver of the work they’re doing,” she said.
And while Trump has for weeks dangled the prospect of testifying, legal experts say that was never likely to happen.
“There was no guarantee that if Trump testified that he would stay on point and not go completely off script in ways that would be, at best, not helpful to the defense and, at worst, harmful to them,” said Richard Serafini, a criminal defense attorney in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and former prosecutor with the U.S. Justice Department.
Krissoff agreed, adding that having a defendant testify can also open the door for other evidence and information to be introduced in trial that could be harmful.
“They’ve done the calculus and decided that they’ve made enough inroads,” she explained, referring to Trump’s lawyers. “They feel they’ve done the damage to the prosecution’s case and they’re going to be able to stand up next week and argue that there isn’t enough to convict the former president.”
If anything, legal experts said, it was surprising that Trump’s lawyers called any witnesses.
The defense’s main witness was attorney Robert Costello, who testified Monday and Tuesday about conversations he had with Cohen in 2018, after the FBI raided Cohen’s home and office. Costello testified that Cohen told him at the time that Trump knew nothing about $130,000 in hush money paid to Daniels.
“I’m not sure that Costello moved the needle in favor of Trump,” said Mark Bederow, a New York criminal defense lawyer and former prosecutor in the Manhattan district attorney’s office. But he and other legal experts said Trump’s lawyers rightly zeroed in on Cohen’s credibility.
Cohen testified that Trump knew all about the scheme to pay off Daniels. But under cross-examination, he also admitted stealing thousands of dollars from Trump’s company and lying during congressional testimony. Cohen also claimed he was innocent of crimes, including tax evasion and bank fraud, despite having pleaded guilty to those crimes in 2018. Cohen said his guilty pleas were, themselves, lies.
“His lack of credibility is just shocking, in terms of his personal bias, his financial motives, his lying and stealing from the company that he was working with, his dishonesty and tape recording his own client,” Bederow said.
One potential witness who never wound up taking the stand was Allen Weisselberg, the former chief financial officer of the Trump Organization. According to the testimony of some witnesses, Weisselberg had knowledge of the payments made to Cohen.
But Weisselberg was sentenced last month to five months in jail for lying under oath during his testimony in the civil fraud lawsuit brought against Trump by New York’s attorney general.
“The problem was neither side could really call him,” Krissoff said. “He’s in custody for lying in a courtroom in the recent past. It was impossible for him to be a credible witness.”
Closing arguments in the trial are expected May 28.
___
Follow Philip Marcelo at twitter.com/philmarcelo.
veryGood! (647)
Related
- Sean Diddy Combs' Lawyers File New Motion for Bail, Claiming Evidence Depicts a Consensual Relationship
- Havana’s once stately homes crumble as their residents live in fear of an imminent collapse
- The House speaker’s race hits an impasse as defeated GOP Rep. Jim Jordan wants to try again
- Who is Raoul A. Cortez? Google Doodle honors Mexican-American broadcaster's birthday
- ‘Maybe Happy Ending’ review: Darren Criss shines in one of the best musicals in years
- Using Google Docs made easy: Four tips and tricks you should know
- Italy suspends open border with Slovenia, citing increased terror threat as Mideast violence spikes
- IRS to test free tax-filing platform in 13 U.S. states. Here's where.
- Mike Tyson concedes the role of villain to young foe in 58-year-old’s fight with Jake Paul
- Lawsuit dropped after school board changes course, adopts Youngkin’s transgender student policy
Ranking
- Biden funded new factories and infrastructure projects, but Trump might get to cut the ribbons
- Tropical Storm Tammy forms in tropical Atlantic heading toward group of islands, forecasters say
- San Francisco police to give update on fatal shooting of driver who crashed into Chinese Consulate
- Not just autoworkers: Grad students make up a growing share of UAW members
- What’s the secret to growing strong, healthy nails?
- Amazon is testing drones to deliver your medications in an hour or less
- When We Were Young in Las Vegas: What to know about 2023 lineup, set times, tickets
- Donald Trump told to keep volume down after getting animated at New York civil fraud trial
Recommendation
-
Tom Brady Admits He Screwed Up as a Dad to Kids With Bridget Moynahan and Gisele Bündchen
-
Sports parents are out of control and officials don't feel safe. Here's what's at risk
-
2 children die in an early morning fire at a Middle Tennessee home
-
New York Jets trading Mecole Hardman back to Kansas City Chiefs
-
Republican Gabe Evans ousts Democratic US Rep. Yadira Caraveo in Colorado
-
A bloody hate crime draws rabbis, Muslims together in mourning for slain 6-year-old boy
-
Why John Stamos Hated Ex Rebecca Romijn During Painful Divorce
-
Pakistan’s ex-leader Nawaz Sharif seeks protection from arrest ahead of return from voluntary exile